The Wrong One

Can't

>>>
Rachel POV
Oh my gosh I can't tell Finn it's his. It'll ruin me. I can't even tell my dads they'll be so disappointed. And I'm kind of scared what they'll do. It's Monday and I've been ignoring puck all day. Finn hasn't even noticed. He's probably screwing some cheerleader in the janitors closet, oh god cheerleading! How am I suppose to be on the Cheerios if I'm pregnant! Coach is going to kill me. I can't tell her. I can't have Finn as the father either, puck's a better guy, he'll be a better father. I just can't tell him. Ugh, and what about glee club! What if they can't accept me either! Oh god my life is such a mess. It's all going downhill because I made one stupid mistake with Finn.
>>>
Puck POV
I kind of feel bad. I didn't hang out with Rachel, instead I let Quinn teach me all about glee club. Plus Rachel joined, and she has such an awesome voice. I just hope she's not mad. But I can't really say anything about Quinn because she hates her. But she's been ignoring me all day which is making me nervous. I mean I really do like Rachel. Oh look there she is.
>>>
"Hey Rachel,"

She walks faster

"Hey, hey, what's wrong?" Puck asks
>>>
Rachel POV
gosh I better be making the right choice

"I'm pregnant" I say with tears glossing over
"M-mine?" He asks shocked
"Yes you, who else?" I say
"But we neve.."
Here goes nothing
"Hot tub?" I said trying to make him buy it
"But we had our clothes on?" He asks still in shock
"My doctor said it was the perfect temperature for sperm" I say making something up
"Are you gonna..."
"No" I interrupt shaking my head

I just cry and he holds me. I can't believe this is happening. No one but puck knows. I'll have to tell someone eventually. I'd never say this out loud but glee's actually enjoyable. I don't know why I've never actually pursued it before, but then I see the glee kids get slushie facials. I'm never one to be cruel, other than to Quinn. I guess that's why they didn't mind when Santana, Britney, and I joined. There's only nine of us. We just need three more people to compete.
>>>
Finn POV
It's been a week and I still can't believe I slept with Rachel. She's been my crush since the seventh grade. I'm still kind of not over the fact she choose to be with puck. Right now puck and I just got out of football practice and he seems so out of it. I stop him in the hallway.

"Dude, what with you?" I ask worried about my bro
"Nothing" he says
"Come on you can tell me" I say
He turns to me
"Rachel's pregnant and she's keeping it" he says in a low whisper scurrying off

At that moment I felt my world crumble down. I know it's mine because she never did it with puck, and I'm the last guy she slept with. Oh man, I screwed up big time.
///
Rachel POV
I haven't told the girls about my situation. I don't want them to worry about me, they're good friends, but I just can't tell them. I already feel really bad about lying to puck. So I'm flying solo right now, then I see him follow me.

"Sup milf" he says
"Leave me alone" I whisper
"Whose the daddy?" Finn asks in a low whisper

I just try to ignore him.

"I just think it's kind of weird, since you told me you were a virgin when we did it, if it's pucks, and I know for a fact you didn't do it with him" he tells me
"How can you be so sure" I ask
"Puck's my boy he would've told me" Finn says so sure of himself
"And do you make it a habit of sleeping with your boys girlfriends" I say walking away

Then I hear

"Well call a Vatican, looks like we got here another immaculate conception" he yells

I pull him in to a secluded spot before he blows my secret

"I'd take care of it you know, you too," he tells me serious "I never had a dad, and I don't roll that way" he tells me once more

I can't have a baby with Finn, I just can't

"Weren't you fired for peeing in a fast food fryer" I ask

"I've got my car business" Finn reasons

"We live in Ohio" I say knowing wants their car fixed from a teenager

There's a pause, and Finn makes a realization face, knowing I'm right

"You know it sucks for you" I say

"You got me drunk off of wine coolers and I was feeling fat that day,"

I tell him

"But it was a mistake.....you're a Lima loser and you're always going to be a Lima loser" I say on the verge of tears, because I still can't believe I'm going to have a baby.

Even the thought of it, makes me want to throw up. And me being pregnant that's exactly what happens, so I hold my mouth as I run to the nearest bathroom.  I already hate this.