The Wrong One

Beth

///
Rachel POV
It's after school and Kurt invited me to go shopping for gaga outfits and help with Tina's new look. So I'm heading to the mall with him as we wait for Tina.
///
In a maternity store
///
"Oh Rachel isn't this cute!" Kurt said excited as held up a pink onsie that said my uncle's better than yours

I just smiled because Kurt is even more excited than I am.

"That is very cute" I agree as I search for a pair of booties

Carols been helping as well, like last week she bought me a pink crib and Finn helped make a room in Santana's house. Everyone is so helpful and I still can't believe Santana and her family are letting me raise the baby with them. I, of course, feel bad so when I get a job, I'm going to buy my own apartment. Shelby also pitches in, yesterday she sent me a package of my pink blanket from when I was born. I appreciated it.

"So what's going on with you and Finn" Kurt asks ready for gossip
"Nothing, besides I'm mad at him" I say while searching racks
"Why?" Kurt asks confused

I stop and look at him

"He wants to name her drizzle" I tell Kurt
"He wants to name my niece drizzle? Ugh, my brothers an idiot!" Kurt tells me
"Tell me about it" I say as we walk out and see Tina

We head to the thrift store and start working on our costumes.
///
Next day
///
Finn POV
Apparently Mr.Schue wants to see both our performances today, so the girls are up first, but before class started I asked if after I could share something. All the guys are sitting as the girls walk in wearing wild outfits. Kurt's in some weird blue suit with high heels and a white wig, Tina is literally bubbles, Quinn is in a checkerboard type costume, and in walks Rachel after a black laced Santana and lobster looking Britney. Rachel is in a pink twirly dress with long pink eyelashes and pink highlights. She looks fabulous, as Kurt says.

All the girls head to the seats as mr.schue claps in amusement

"Ahahaha, take a bow little monsters" mr.schue says walking in

All the girls, plus Kurt, start posing and making noises. Soon enough after mr.shue takes roll, the girls head to the auditorium.

*perform bad romance

We all cheer and woo hoo. After the girls head to the rows in the audience, us guys go and change into our costumes.
///
Rachel POV
Performing gets harder and harder as I hit a new month, now. We just finished bad romance and now we're in the audience waiting for the guys performance. The guys weren't down with gaga so now they're doing kiss. I'm so excited to see the boys.

"This should be fun" Santana whispers as the guys come on stage in hardcore outfits

She sits back down as Artie starts off

"LIMA,OHIO! ARE YOU READY TO ROCK?"

We all cheer and nod in agreement. Soon enough the boys are performing shout. I must say they sound pretty good, but they look ridiculous. Especially Finn with his tongue sticking out. I couldn't help but laugh and cheer along.
///
Finn POV
Once we finished mr.schue told the girls to head to the choir room. Quickly I run out to wipe off all the heavy makeup. The boys sort of rush as well because I need them in order for this to work.

*they finish cleaning

I walk in, I stand in the middle for a moment before I start,

"I want to tell Rachel something, and I want everybody to hear it"

I look at her and she looks a little confused

"I know you don't want to name her drizzle and I should've been more supportive and understanding because drizzle may sound cool for like a powerboat or something, but not a baby girl, so if my kiss mates will help me out, I have something better in mind"

They all get up as I grab a stool. They do the same and sit around me. The piano dude starts playing and I let the music flow

Beth I hear you calling
But I can't come home right now
Me and the boys are playing
And we just can't find the sound
Just a few more hours
And I'll be right home to you
I think I hear them calling
Oh Beth what can I do
Beth what can I do
You say you feel so empty
That our house just ain't our home
I'm always somewhere else
And you're always there alone
Just a few more hours
And I'll be right home to you
I think I hear them calling
Oh Beth what can I do
Beth what can I do
Beth I know you're lonely
And I hope you'll be alright
'Cause me and the boys will be playing all night

I finish and the whole time I'm looking at Rachel. She has a couple tears but she gives me a tiny little smile. I get up and go to her

"I know you're still not sure what you're going to do, but before you decide, I think you should name her beth" I say looking down

I check and see her smiling

"And I'd really like to be apart of her life, if you let me" I assure trying not to push my luck

Rachel smiles even more and let's, hopefully, happy tears fall. I look at her and she hugs me. At first I'm tense but I naturally fall into her arms. The whole club aww's. For a moment it feels like everything is going to be ok.