The Wrong One

We're Engaged!

///
Rachel POV
I sat down with Finn in the front row holding hands as puck began playing his guitar.

Please baby can't you see
My mind's a burnin' hell
I got razors a rippin' and tearin' and strippin'
My heart apart as well
Tonight you told me
That you ache for something new
And some other woman is lookin' like something
That might be good for you

So far he's only been looking at me, and it's making me uncomfortable.

Go on and hold her till the screaming is gone
Go on believe her when she tells you nothing's wrong

But I'm the only one
Who'll walk across the fire for you
I'm the only one
Who'll drown in my desire for you
It's only fear that makes you run
The demons that you're hiding from
When all your promises are gone
I'm the only one

Finn POV
What the hell!? He's obviously singing the song for her. Who does he think he is? Rachel is my fiancé.
///
Quinn POV
Oh my god, he is not,
///

Please baby can't you see
I'm trying to explain
I've been here before and I'm locking the door
And I'm not going back again
Her eyes and arms and skin won't make it go away
You'll wake up tomorrow and wrestle the sorrow
That holds you down today

Go on and hold her till the screaming is gone
Go on believe her when she tells you nothing's wrong

But I'm the only one
Who'll walk across the fire for you
I'm the only one
Who'll drown in my desire for you
It's only fear that makes you run
The demons that you're hiding from
When all your promises are gone
I'm the only one

Go on and hold her till the screaming is gone
Go on believe her when she tells you nothing's wrong

///
Rachel POV
Oh god, Finn looks pissed off. I keep holding his hand to show him, I love him. But I can already tell this isn't going to end well
///

But I'm the only one
Who'll walk across the fire for you
And I'm the only one
Who'll drown in my desire for you
It's only fear that makes you run
The demons that you're hiding from
When all your promises are gone
I'm the only one

And I'm the only one
Who'll drown in my desire for you
It's only fear that makes you run
The demons that you're hiding from
When all your promises are gone
I'm the only one
///
Still Rachel POV
As soon as puck finished he smiled at me as we all awkwardly clapped. I'm pretty sure no one knew what to say. Hell I don't even know. I don't feel that way about puck. He needs to understand, which is why Finn and I should tell them our news.

"What at the hell man!??" Finn asked pissed
"What?" Puck asked mad too
"Don't you think it's inappropriate for you to be singing love songs to my fiancé?" Finn asked mad

I could hear everyone gasp, including puck. Great now he's done it.

"Fi-an what now?" Mercedes asked

I hold Finn hand as we walk to the center, puck still has a look of shock. Everyone is asking a bunch of questions at once and Mr.schue looks as shocked as everybody else.

"You heard correctly, Finn and I are engaged!" I say excited showing them my ring
"Don't you think you're both a little young to be getting married?" Kurt asked
"Well I'm happy for you guys, go team finchel!" Tina yelled
"Looks like finchel is getting hitched, I'm in" Mercedes adds
"Congrats you guys!" Sam and mike say
"Thank you everyone, and Kurt, I love Finn,"
Finn interrupts
"And I love Rachel"
I smile even more as I continue
"So, Yes, we're a little more young then the normal couples, but we're not any less in love, so I hope you all support us because I'd really like to see you all there" I finish

Mr.schue recovers from our news and pats Finns back

"I'm happy for you guys" mr.schue says

I look at Kurt figuring something in his head out. He's like battling with himself. Finally he speaks

"You know what, I call wedding planner, if this is really happening" Kurt says

I smile and I feel Finn grinning so I look to see his big old smile. Everyone is surprisingly handling this better than I thought. I kiss Finns cheek because he was right. I'm so happy everyone's happy for us

*sees puck slouching

Well almost everyone.