Creepypasta x Reader

Eyeless Jack (Part 3)

(((A/N: Last part of this triology.)))

The next day, you woke up with a pair of pitch black eyes above your face. You screamed and immediately punched the person out of reflex. "Ow. I probably deserved that." The being said. You realized it was EJ and quickly began to apologize. "Oh jesus, sorry EJ. Oh my god, are you okay? You scared the shit outta me." You said, sitting up, rubbing your eyes. He got up from the floor and laughed. "It's alright, sorry for waking you up like that." He said.

"Wait, why were you hovering above me in the first place?" You asked. "Uh...I don't know. You're cute I guess." He said, scratching the back of his neck. You blushed. "Oh...thanks?" You didn't really know how to answer that. "W-well, I'm gonna make some food I guess." You said, getting up to go to the kitchen. "Ok." He said, following you. You opened the fridge and grabbed some stuff to eat. "You want anything?" You asked him. "You." He answered very quietly. "W-what?" You stuttered.

"Oh! Sorry, did I say that out loud?? Shit..um..."

"EJ, a-are you saying that y-you...um.." You kept stuttering.

"Yeah, fuck it, I really like you, (y/n). I basically stalked you because you're so beautiful and I just... I don't know. I'm sorry if I creeped you out and you don't have to like me back or anything."

"Y-you like me?" You were blushing like crazy now.

"Yeah. I do. But you wouldn't like me, especially since my job is to...murder people." He finally let out. "EJ. I don't care what your job is. I'm not gonna lie, I really like you too. So if you're asking me out, it's a yes." You smiled as he came over to hug you. You hugged him back.

After about a month of being with EJ, you still haven't seen his face. Heck, you haven't even kissed him yet. You were a bit ticked off, but otherwise, happy. He'd visit everyday, sometimes sleep over. Today, you were determined to get that damn mask off. You are his girlfriend, did he really think you'd leave him for a disfigured face, if it even was disfigured at all? You decided that the second he got home, you were gonna jump on his back and remove the mask.

After another hour, you heard the front door open, so you hid next to the door and jumped on EJ's back and tried grabbing the mask. "W-what the hell?!" He yelled, flipping you off his back onto the ground, about to stab you with his scalpel. You flinched, scared for your life. "S-shit, (y/n), I'm so sorry. Are you okay, beautiful?" He said, kneeling down next to you, putting his scalpel away. "Y-yeah. Sorry for scaring you." He helped you up and held you. "Please don't ever do that again." He said rubbing your back. "I'm sorry, EJ. I just want to see your face..." You said looking down on the floor. "I know it shouldn't matter, but I have to know... EJ, I would never leave you for your appearance."

He was silent for a few minutes before taking your hands and putting them on his mask. You gave him a questionable look and he nodded in reply. You slowly removed the mask, hearing his breath hitch. You revealed an attractive face, with grey-ish skin and pitch black eyes. You started blushing because he was pretty hot. "W-what? Why a-are you blushing? Is it t-that bad?" He said immediately reaching for his mask. "No! No, no, no! Keep the mask off!" You said throwing it over to the living room. "You're really cute." You said, smiling and hugging him. You looked up at him before smashing your lips against his. He immediately kissed back, quickly getting dominance over you. The taste of blood was on his lips, which kind of confused you, but you didn't care, it tasted pretty good. The kiss went from sweet to intense instantly and you both were getting pretty heated. Unfortunately the kiss had to end because the need for air was overcoming the need for kissing.

You both were breathing pretty heavily while holding each other. "You have no idea how long I've been waiting to do that." He said between breaths. You smiled. "Can I ask why your lips taste like blood?" You asked. He kinda looked away, nervous. "I'm a cannibal..." He said. "Cool, I think I might be now too...it tasted good." You confessed. He smiled and you two returned to making out, but this time EJ made it more intense by wrapping your legs around his waist and pinning you against a wall. He began kissing you on your neck and jawline, making you moan.

He kept searching for your sweet spot and when he found it, you squeaked, making him smirk. He started to suck on that spot, which is when you found out that he had sharp teeth, which made this even more pleasurable. You moaned louder and dug your nails into his back. Your face was super flushed as he gave you more and more hickeys. He kissed you up your jawline and bit your earlobe, which is when you lost it and took your legs off of him and you shoved him in your room and pushed him down on your bed, harshly. You pinned him down and it was your turn to bite his damn neck. You gave him a bunch of hickeys as well, making him moan. He flipped you over, so he was now on top of you. He returned his mouth to your sweet spot and sucked at it again, causing you to buck your hips against his. He smirked.

Let's just say, your night was very magical.