Chapter 4: Did It Have To Be Eggs?

24 4 1
                                    

Chapter 4: Did It Have To Be Eggs?

As soon as we enter the bathroom, Evan locks the door.

"You know," I say hesitantly, "I think I will be traumatized. Can I leave now?"

Evan whips to me, no longer smiling.

"Or maybe not," I mumble under my breath.

I watch as the boy pulls out his phone from the pockets of his hoodie.

He types something and hands it to me.

Type in your phone number.

I furrow my brow in confusion.

Why?

He rolls his eyes.

We're wasting time. Just do it.

I still don't get it, but I comply nonetheless.

"Well this is a weird way to ask for a phone number," I mutter to myself.

As I put it in, I can't help but add:

Anyway, I don't understand what my number has to do with this dare.

I might sound dumb, but I mean, come on! An attractive (yes, I hate to admit he's attractive), guy asked (well, demanded), for my number!

After a few moments, I hear my phone chime. I quickly read it.

I need to talk to you, and I figure this is the best method.

"So... what do you want to talk about?" I ask.

He shoots me an annoyed look. "No talking," he mouths silently. "Just type!"

"Fine," I groan. "Just tell me already!"

For the first time, mischief shows in Evan's eyes.

As my phone chimes, I can't help but feel suspicious. What compelled him to 'talk' to me like this?

I feel my insides turn to ice at his answer.

I know your secret.

I try not to let any emotion cross my face.

Damn! What mistake did I make this time?

No matter. I need to make him believe my lie, and quick.

I fake a grin and I'm about to lie when Evan points at his phone, gesturing not to talk, but to type in my response.

I roll my eyes.

What secret? And why are we "conversing" like this?

I press send. His phone chimes, and when he reads my answer, he looks at me as if I'm the weird one.

We are talking like this because I bet you fifty bucks that everyone's trying to eavesdrop. And don't act like you're so clueless. You know what I'm talking about.

I scoff at his reply. If he thinks I'm going to confess, he's wrong. But he's not wrong about everyone trying to eavesdrop.

No, I have no idea what your talking about, Evan. Please, enlighten me.

The boy in question smirks at me.

Really, Elizabeth? Or should I say, Agatha?

My eyes meet him, wild and frantic. My fingers shakily type the response.

HOW DO YOU KNOW THAT?!?

Yes. I use capital letters for situations like these.

It was quite easy, believe me. Do you want to know how?

Rejection Hurts On Both SidesWhere stories live. Discover now