Tate x Reader twisted nerve

Unsettling feeling.

Today I went to the library for lunch break, I sat towards the back so no one would bother me. I had hoped that I could at least get 15 minutes of privacy until a group of girls walked in. They seemed normal and looked like they were trying to hide something. I pretended I was listening to music from my phone. The girls walked passed me and sat at the nearest table.

"Okay, like I was saying since its Halloween we have stay here!" The girl with the green hoodie said.

"Why? It's pointless" the second girl with long blonde hair asked.

The third girl who wore a lot of eye-shadow scoffed. "How can you say that celeste... you know that you've brought this idea to us in the first place. So let's just stick with the plan and stay here tonight. I'll bring my brothers Ouija board and Kim can bring the other essentials."

This conversation had me very interested. I wanted to ask them what they were planning to do...

"What are you guys planning?" I said turning towards them. The three girls looked at me.

"We want to talk to the kids that died in this library." Kim said.

"We heard that on the night of Halloween they appear. They are usually seen here around the school. Right Camilee?" said Celeste.

"Yeah, I want to see if the rumors are true... Hey you're (y/n) Right?" Camilee said.

"Yeah that's me..." I answered.

"Oh my god... you have to be a part of this! You live in the murderer's house!" Camilee said excitedly. She stood up from her chair and held her hands to her chest.

"What do you mean...? The person who killed the people in here, used to live where I do now?" I asked.

"Yes, in fact... That's where he died. I don't think this is a coincidence at all. You have to come with us tonight." Camilee said.

"I'm Sorry but I have other plans tonight..." I said monotonously. I left the library in a hurry and went to the bathroom.

Well... that was weird... It's like everyone knows I live there. I wonder who the murderer was... I looked at my phone went to google and put in the date, the school name and murderer in the search box. I was about to press enter until I accidently dropped my phone. I walked out of the bathroom after I picked my phone, I walked towards my locker and seen Josiah standing there. Whatever, I'm just going to go straight to class. I walk past him and he calls out to me. Ignore him and keep walking.

After a long day of school I finally get home. I lay in my bed and turn on some nice music I like. Honestly all I could think about was Tate.

Time skip to night time---------------------------------------

Mom and Dad went out to a party... they asked if I wanted to come but I said I would just hand out candy. I heard knocking and grabbed the candy bag assuming it was a child. When I opened the door I was kind of surprised no one was there. I closed the door and sat down on the couch. Then I had this creepy feeling. Like someone was watching me intensely. I tried to ignore it but the strange feeling became worse. I felt paralyzed, like I was too scared to move. Then I jumped in shock when I heard a loud bang coming from the basement. I got up and ran towards the front door. I decided I was just going to go for a walk. Staying inside the house, was making me feel ill...

I opened the door to see Tate standing there.
"Hi (y/n)"
I smiled shyly and walked outside. He followed behind me.
"Tate... I was expecting you..."
He took a hold of my hand and stopped me so that now I was looking at him.
"I'm sorry... I have been ignoring you. It's... well, I was afraid of getting closer to you and now... I feel like you and I are meant to be together... I want to protect you, and cherish you. I will never leave you. You'll never be alone..."
Tate hugged me strongly and I hugged him back.

Later that night Tate told me he wanted to take me to his special place. We spent the night there and I felt like the happiest person...

"Can I kiss you?" Tate asked.
I nodded. And he immediately kissed me and I was startled at first but I slowly started to kiss him back. He lightly pushed me down; continued kissing me softly. I held his face in my hand and he softly caressed my hair.
"Are you, a virgin?" Tate asked.
I blushed.
"Yeah, but Tate... if you're thinking of doing it... now... I, I'm not-"

"Don't worry, whenever you are ready I will wait. I asked because, it was something I thought about for a while." Tate said honestly.

"I guess I'm the abnormal one these days." I say smiling sadly.

"Who cares, at least you have your dignity...and what's wrong with being abnormal?" Tate says.

He kissed me once more and held me close to his chest.

"I was scared... that you wouldn't want me." Tate said after a comfortable silence.
"What do you mean?" I asked.

"I was afraid you wouldn't like me and felt that I would because you pain... but the days I spent away from you made it worse for me. I really like you (y/n)... I never felt this way for anyone before."

I felt so in love and pulled in by his words. I wanted him to keep telling me these beautiful things. However, deep down I felt a strange unwavering feeling in the pit of my stomach. I try to ignore it. Ever since I've met him I tried.... I couldn't fully, truly trust Tate...