The First Smile, Reborn

A Love Forbidden

(Eves POV)

I stared at the girl standing, knowing who she was, I felt quite.. furious. If this was her way to save Add, she was wrong. I didn't feel anything but betrayal. I attempted to reach out to stop her, but then heard steps from behind me. I turned around, to see Lu and Ciel. Lu smiled, as did Ciel. "Eve!!" She ran towards me and wrapped her warmth around me. Her tight hold reminded me of Add. "Is something wrong?" Lu's grip tightened, Ciel looked me in the eye and I could tell he was trying to unwind something that could yet be determined. "Please stop Ruki from giving herself up!"

The sudden outburst made me a tad bit happier. I, too, didn't want to give Add up to anyone else. The idea was too much. Was Rosemary truly this lonely? I could tell she was sad, but her reasons were something of that of love. I bit my lip then turned to the screen. I could see Rosemary shivering, "She's.. an idiot." I mumbled under my breath, but I'm sure they heard me. Ciel stared at me as did Lu,
"She just wants to be loved but doing it like that won't get her anywhere. Rosemary will be found out soon and if she keeps that tough act, nothing will come out of it." They stared harder, and I realized I gave away Rosemary's lie. "R-Rosemary?! You know where she is?!" Lu looked deep in my eyes, utterly determined to find out where Rosemary is. "Lu.. Ruki is Rosemary." Ciel's words dripped with sorrow as he faced the floor. Lu stared at Ciel and I in disbelief.

"No. Rosemary wouldn't do that! She loves Sukimi and Ciel! Why would she do that?!" I sat back in my chair that faced the screen, "She.. wants to protect both of you."

I could feel Lu's tears inside, slowly making me sad and break out in a few tears. I loved Rosemary as well. She's done so much in everyone's lives, even if they don't know it. Her words of encouragement echoed in my mind, she just wanted to save Add. I could tell that. I knew she just wanted to help me save Add from the ill state he was put in because of my sudden disappearance. I shook for a moment, realizing the bad things I said of her. "Please, keep acting like you don't know her. She just wants to be who she is, truly. She wants to save Add, from himself." I looked up at the monitor, seeing Rosemary smile with the other members she was with.

"I know she wants happiness.." Ciel looked down at the ground, as if his feelings were invalid for her. "Don't act like your the victim. Your the one who decides to jump from Sukimi to Rosemary." I could see him look up at me in regret, pitiful. "Hey! Ciel didn't know how he felt! He was confused! But now he knows! He loves Sukimi!" I smiled at the word love, "And I Love Add.."