Sins [Jeff the killer x reader]

Jeff the killer?

Present time

~

Readers pov*

"well there you have it" you said sighing, not even noticing the tear falling down your face, Jeff then reached his arm and wiped your cheek with his thumb,

"hey, don't cry" Jeff said in a soft voice, then you slightly pushed his arm away and wiped your face on your own,

why was Jeff being so nice? it's making me uncomfortable. you thought to yourself,

"i-i wasn't crying" you insisted, Jeff, laughed a bit at your words. After you rid your face of the tears you looked at Jeff who had a slight pink tint to his pale cheeks he was also just staring at you, you quickly looked away heat rising in your cheeks,

"well" you cleared your throat, turning back to Jeff to see he's snapped out of his stare,

"if you have any questions just ask" you offered, he just looks at you thinking for a moment before it appears he has a question,

"so that old guy in the story, he was god right?" Jeff asked,

"yes" you answered,

"how exactly did you find out he was god?" Jeff questioned,

"i did a lot of research on the matter. Once i figured out how to use a computer" you jokingly said the last part, laughing slightly Jeff did also,

"so i have another question" Jeff says, you nod

"how long were you in that cage?" he inquired of you,

"uh" you thought for a moment,

"till about 3 years ago" you answer, looking at Jeff sadness on his face barely noticeable,

"i-i see, one more thing" Jeff whispers, you look at him and nod once again,

"how did you get out of that cage?"Jeff asks, you slightly tense up at the question before you answer,

"Acedia got me out" you answered,

"but why after so long?" Jeff questioned,

"because" you took a deep breath,

"she wants me to kill her and the others" you revealed, Jeff looks at you with slight shock,

"why w-" you cut him off,

"i don't know why but she said to me that they have all changed, and not for the better" you say, Jeff just continues to look at you not knowing what to say,

"I think living this long may have done something to them, but i'm not one to talk, i mean I've lived just as long" you say, looking down at the table trying to hold back tears, Jeff notices this and reaches his hands and cups both of your cheeks

"hey (Y/n)! you're different, your probably one of the kindest and caring people I've meet I mean I literally killed you and you still treat me as if I was any other normal person" Jeff says trailing off, your cheeks in this moment feel like there literally gunna EXPLODE!! (from embarrassment lol) also your heart was beating exponentially fast, so before Jeff can say anything else, you remove his hands from your cheeks and you slowly get up from your seat and slowly back away, Jeff is now very confused.

"uh i-i-i have to go get changed now" you stutter cheeks as red as ever, Jeff opens his mouth to speak but before he can you teleport to your room. Once you appear in your room you walk over to your mirror and look at yourself, your stare for a moment examining your body you were wearing (f/c) pj shorts with (f/a) (fave animal) on them and a plain baggy black t-shirt. you then look at your face a blush still faint on your cheeks and you touch your cheeks, where Jeff had his hands a few moments earlier before you knew it you felt a smile on your face,