Can We Save Us? | Sequel to I Hate You But I Love You | Ambrollins

Chapter 13: There Was No Way....

A/N: Honestly, I don't know how I typed this but I did 😲 

**********

Seth's POV:

After saying goodbye to the kids, I went back to Hunter's house. Hunter asked the men if I tried to run off or anything, making me roll my eyes. I put a fake smile on my face before approaching him.

"Do you really think I'd tell the cops on you?" I asked, wrapping my arms around his neck as I pouted.

"I just wanted to make sure." he said, wrapping his arms around my waist. I hated being in this position with him. I wanted it to be with Dean but I just had to wait.

"Well, you don't have to. Like I said, I'm willing to try and make this work but that means you have to trust me, okay?"

Hunter sighed before nodding. "Okay, I'm trusting you."

Yeah, bad idea...

"As much as it pains me, kiss him, make out with him and I really hate saying this but if it comes to the point where the only way of gaining his trust is by having sex with him, do it."

I bit the inside of my cheek as I remembered what Dean told me. I hated this so much but I guess it had to be done. I literally wanted to puke. I smirked at Hunter and pulled away from him.

"Where are you going?" he smirked.

"Well...." I said, backing towards the couch. "If you want me, come and get me."

Hunter smirked and made his way towards me. This was going to be literal hell for me. But then I remembered, this is all for Dean and our family. If I want them back, I need to put my heart into this. I can't be hesitant for even a moment. Hunter pulled me onto the sofa on top of him and started kissing me. I had no choice but to kiss him back. I wasn't going to lie, he was a good kisser.

Hunter started squeezing my ass, making me moan slightly. I mean, come on. If someone does that to you, you're gonna have to let it out. I grabbed his hand and moved it away from my ass. I did not need him doing that anymore. Hunter soon pulled away and smiled slightly.

"Wow." he said. "I definitely didn't get kisses like that from Stephanie."

"Oh really? Do I need to prove that I'm better than her?" I smirked.

"You already proved that a long time ago." he smirked. "I..um...I wanted to give you something."

He got up and left the room before coming back a few moments later with a large object that was gift wrapped.

"What's that?" I asked confused as he sat next to me.

"It's a little something from me." he said. "Open it."

I tore off the wrapping paper and saw this. 

"What is this for?" I asked, looking at the photo.

"I was really proud of you that day. I really was. You made me proud to admit that I had feelings for you. It was one of the best days of my life because it was the day your dream came true."

"It..it was?" I asked. I was shocked with what he was saying.

"Yeah, it was. You mean a lot to me Seth. I know I've done horrible things but they're all for you. You make me happy by being happy yourself. That day at Wrestlemania, I was over the moon. I was so happy you finally achieved your dream." he said. "I gotta go now. I have a meeting but I'll see you later, okay."

I nodded and I felt him kiss my cheek before he left. I stared at the picture for a while. Did he actually feel that way? Am I being wrong by messing with his feelings for me? Is he actually a good person or not?

I felt like I was turning into a horrible person for playing with Hunter's feelings. If he has genuine feelings for me, what I was doing was so wrong. I ran up to my room and locked my door before pulling out the phone Dean gave me and I started texting him.

"Dean, I don't feel right doing this."

"What's wrong?"

"I feel like Hunter has genuine feelings for me and I feel bad for messing with them."

"Seth, you can't be serious. Don't tell me you're gonna start falling for him too."

"No, but I don't like this. I feel like a horrible person."

"Seth, you can't forget what he did to us. Remember all that shit he put us through. He broke us up and tried to kill Tyler. Then he tried to kidnap our kids from school."

"I guess you're right. I'll talk to you later. I love you xx"

"I love you too xx"

**********

A Few Hours Later

I was eating dinner when Hunter returned home.

"Hey." 

"Hey." I said. "I realize I haven't said thank you for the present so thank you. It was really...sweet of you."

"It was no problem. I just want you to know that my feelings for you are real. I really do love you and I want this to go well."

I stared at him for a while, trying to figure out how I felt right now. He sent me a warm smile and all of a sudden, I felt butterflies in my stomach. There was no way.

There was no way I was falling for Hunter.....right?