Snapped (Reader x Jeff)

Fuck off!

I kept struggling to get away as the crowd of creepypastas traveled through the forest. I got more desperate as we got closer. Eventually Slenderman and Riley appeared in view and the crowd rushed forward.

Jeff's grip loosened in shock and I took the opportunity to escape. "Friendly!" Slenderman and Riley stared at us. Riley smiled."Y/N! You came back." She looked behind me. "Obviously not of your free will." She frowned sympathetically. "Even the people you call friends don't listen." I felt weak again. Jeff stepped forward. I glared at him. She's right. "Friendly you really believe her? We all care about you! You're one of us!" I backed away. "Of course Y/N is. Slenderman didn't really give 'Friendly' a choice." I clenched my fist. "No, he didn't!" I backed up even farther and a shadow fell over me.

"Friendly!!" Jeff called out, fear in his eyes. He's scared of me...? I looked behind me, hoping to see something else that he would be scared of. Nothing was there. Of course he's scared. He doesn't want to lose his toy! I looked to my right. Riley smiled sweetly. "Hello Y/N." She held out her hand. "I won't control you. This is your choice. Together?" I hesitated. I hadn't even realized I had walked into the darkness. But Riley was standing with me. Her skin glimmered in the shadows and she looked genuine. Unlike the still faces and silent mouths that stood outside. I raised my hand slightly. "Y/N what the hell!" EJ was standing right outside the circle. He's mad. He hates me. EJ raised his hand and I flinched. Instead of hitting me or grabbing me, he pulled off his mask. I stared as the blue mask dropped to the ground.

I stared at his ashy brown hair that hung over empty sockets and black tears. His mouth was open, revealing the gray tongue to match his skin and the pointy fangs he had for teeth. Toby stood next to him and pulled off his masks and goggles. A large scar on the left side of his mouth revealed his teeth. Slowly, one by one everyone stepped closer and pulled down hoods and took off masks. Why are they doing this?

Jeff stepped forward. "See! We all trust you! Please don't do this Friendly!" Go on. Take her hand. If you change your mind I'll be right here. I swung my head to look at Slenderman. With no features I couldn't exactly read his facial expression, but he gave the smallest tilt of his head. He doesn't even want me... In a moment of pure hate, I grabbed Riley's hand. She glowed golden light and enveloped me in her arms for a hug.