Snapped (Reader x Jeff)

The First Argument

Jeff's P.O.V.

It was great. Terrorizing the others with our sappy skits or moaning loudly when we were just playing a video game or something, just to fuck with everyone. Hell I even blackmailed Jack into moaning with us for kidneys!! God that was the best! BEN got so freaked out and banged on our bedroom door. "YOU GUYS NEED TO KEEP IT DOWN! JESUS CHRIST!" Jack got into the mood and yelled back. "You're just jealous Benny-Boy!" That shut up BEN.

Friendly was the best cuddler and always burst into sputtering every time I did something risky. They were adorable though. And we were honestly so cheesy sometimes. We'd hold hands going hunting and kiss over a dead body. God, it was kinda romantic!

After we cooled our excitement, (Can you blame us? I love murdering! Screams of horror are so pleasant honestly!) we'd sit in the living room watching BEN playing video games, making "suggestive" sounds to piss him off. Or we'd grab the controller and kill the character. After the first few times BEN refused to let us in to watch him.

Then Masky and Jack happened.

God it pissed mE OFF SO MUCH! I was ready to kill them after what they did! Slenderman says it was an accident but I don't care!!

So, I had convinced Jack and Friendly to play tag with me and Sally. So Jack and Friendly were running down the hall when Masky, stumbled into the hall, bottle in hand. He fell into Jack who landed on top Friendly and they froze their for a entire SECOND before Jack crawled off and yelled at Masky for drinking. Friendly stood up and brushed themself off. Until they had to restrain me from attacking Jack. "Jeff what the hell??" "I'M GONNA MURDER HIM!" Sally burst into tears, screaming about how she liked Jack and Masky.

Slenderman appeared from nowhere and picked her up. "Jeffery." I snarled and spun my head to glare at him. "JACK LAID ON TOP OF THEM! I'M GONNA CUT HIM OPEN WITH HIS OWN SCALPEL! HE DESERVES TO SLEEP!" Jack and Masky jumped away from me, their masks staring. I lunged but Friendly pulled me back and twisted my arms behind my back. I bit my lip and tugged harshly. Their grip loosened and I twisted away but then I was wrapped in a black tendril. "LET ME AT THE HORNY IDIOTS!" I twisted and turned, trying to get away. "Jeff!"

I whirled my head around and made eye contact with Friendly. They looked back with fear and concern. I froze, before going limp. Slenderman dropped me on the ground and I winced, landing on my back. Jack and Masky tried to push each other in front as if they could use the other person as a shield. I glared but stayed on the ground. Everyone slowly relaxed and footsteps came from different sides of the house as the crowd grew around us.

Friendly refused to accept my apology.

"Jeff why are you apologizing to me!? It's Jack and Masky who's life you threatened!" I growled. "I refuse to apologize to those assholes!" Friendly rolled their eyes and glared at me. "Why are you apologizing to me at least?" "I got you into that mess! If I hadn't invited you too play you would've been in your room!" "Goddamit Jeff! That's not even a valid reason! You should be apologizing for flipping out on me because of a little accident! He wasn't even trying to stay down! He was barely down for a second! He was dazed!" "I don't give a damn! I don't wanna have to worried about random people laying on you! Besides! Masky was drunk-ish and would've gladly started doing dumb shit!!" Friendly sighed and facepalmed. "But that didn't happen! So it doesn't matter." I grabbed their wrist and gave them a pleading look. Their face softened slightly but they turned away. "No Jeff. You can't puppy-dog this. Apologize like a decent person!"