What Hurts The Most (Gwuncan)

Monday 12:00 AM: "What could have been"

   My eyes had to be deceiving me. I left the real world to leave her, why was she here now? I looked at her and she stared back at me. Just as I was about to open my mouth the man in the white tux appeared in between us. "Well isn't this great, you are both here." he said politely as if amused by this. "Please tell me she's going to heaven." I said eagerly, waiting for his reply as if it were life or death. "She won't be seeing the gates of heaven, sadly. However she will be entering Hell, but there is good news for you and Duncan" he said placing a hand on my shoulder. "But I will need both of you here" he added before clapping his hands and Duncan appearing next to him.
      "What the Hell just happened?" Duncan said. "There is good news for you both depending on what you choose." the man in the tux said. I saw Duncan realize that Courtney was next to him and he instantly walked to the other side of the man in tux. "Courtney I will escort you to hell in a few just take a seat in the lobby" the tux man said gesturing to the seats, as Courtney made her way to the seats with worry in her eyes. "What's the good news?" Duncan questioned, the man in the tux cleared his throat and pulled out a paper. "You two have two choices, one of the choices is that you both go to hell and suffer for eternity or both go back to earth but live as if you never knew each other at all, we will wipe both your memories and you will also be sending Courtney back with you and her memory will be wiped cleaned as well up until you two met each other." he said placing the paper back into his pocket.
     I looked at Duncan, questioning if living was in hell for eternity with him suffering was worth it just to be together. I guess he was thinking the same thing because he looked at the man in the tux before saying "So if we go back how will our life be?" the man in the tux snapped his fingers and images appeared.

Gwen will meet Noah and they will get married.

Duncan will end up with Heather.

And Courtney and Trent will stay together.

    I locked eyes with Duncan and got curious. "Could you show us what would have happened if we both stayed alive?" I said, making the man in the tux smile. "I'm glad you asked, I was actually rooting for you two to be together because your future looked beautiful but you could see for yourself" and just as he finished his last word he snapped his fingers again. Before images flashed in front of us.

You would've made a family.

You and Courtney would have been friends.

And you both would have grown old together.

    "So what's it going to be, are you going back to earth or want eternity in hell?"