(Smut warning, if you don't want to read it, skip to where it says smut ending)
Kissing her I picked her up, and she wrapped her legs around my waist. Holding her up against the wall kissing her again.
Continued...
~Finn~
I moved her onto the bed, kissing her. Leaning her back so her back was on the bed, she smirked at me. I was over her kissing her neck, moving down to her chest, leaving hickeys. She flipped, so she was straddling me. She started kissing me lower leaving hickeys on my chest and stomach. Still sitting on my waist moving her hips into me.
She sat up still straddling me, and pulled my shirt gesturing me to sit up to. She took of her shirt throwing it across the room. I took off my shirt. She kissed me leaning me back down so my back was on the bed and she was straddled on top of my waist still moving her hips into me.Her hands were in my hair kissing me. She took her hands off my face continuing to kiss me. She paused for a second do take off her shorts. She kissed me again and moved her hand down. I looked down to see what she was doing. "I got it Wolfhard" she whispered biting her lip, starting to undo my pants.
She turned so I was on top of her. We we making out and I moved down leaving hickeys on her neck. We took of our underwear and continued making out.
I pushed into her making her let out a moan. "Is this okay" I asked quietly, she nodded biting down on her lip. I kissed her neck, thrusting into her faster. "Fuck, Finn" she moaned as she put her head back. I slowly picked up the pace making her moan louder. "Fuck" I moaned softly into her ear, continuing to kiss her every so often.
I picked up the pace making her moan louder, "oh god" she moaned loudly. She grabbed my back digging her finger nails into it, leaving marks and scratches. "Good?" I asked slowing down. "Keep going baby" she moaned loudly. I picked up the pace again, speeding up more than I had been. "Oh god....oh god Finn" she screamed.
"I'm close" I moaned to Caiti. She continued moaning as she scratched my back harder. "Fuck" I moaned as I finished rolling over to the side of Caiti. "
(Smut ending)
"Wow" I said catching my breath. "Wow" she sighed back catching her breath. "Are you sure that was your first time" she asked standing up, I nodded "How many people have you been with" I asked.
~Caiti~
How many people have you been with" Finn asked. "Why" I replied back quickly. He shrugged "I was just wondering", "Well before I tell you, tell me how many girls you've been with" I said grabbing my clothes putting them back on. He hesitated for a second "One" he answered smiling. "One? How? Have you seen what you look like" I asked confused.
"Well" he got up putting on sweat pants. "I was single all of highschool, and then I started dating you" he smiled. "One though" I looked at Finn as I pulled my shirt on. "What about it" he chuckled. "How" I sighed. "I don't know I guess I have only slept with people I've been in love with" he looked down starting to walk towards me.
"But you have only slept with me" I stuttered confused. He walked over to me "Right" he sighed looking down again. "Oh w-wow " I said turning around smiling to myself putting my head in my hands. I turned around facing him again. "You know I love you too right" I said putting my arms around his neck. He smiled putting his arms around my waist. "Now I do" he smiled pulling me in and kissing me.