Sincerely Mine

Chapter 5

(Y/N) trembles in Alastor's grip, tears streaming down her cheeks as she struggles to hold back a sob.
"Why do you insist on leaving me? " Whispers Alastor into (Y/N)'s ear.
(Y/N) just whimpers and shakes her head, keeping her mouth shut tight.
"Well if you're not gonna talk then I know a way to make you" Chuckles Alastor as he drags the tip of the blade towards her hip. "You know dear, there's a nice little nerve here that, if cut, sprouts out a lot of blood. At least a bucket worth. I already told you that I find the smell of your blood intoxicating but I doubt you'd enjoy that feeling as much as I do. " He smirks as he begins humming gently.
"P-please n-no please" (Y/N) stutters helplessly as she begins crying.
"Aww sweetie no tears. They don't suit your pretty face. Besides I hate seeing you upset. How about you smile for me? You know you're never fully dressed without one" Alastor chuckles as he holds (Y/N) close.
(Y/N) tries to grab the knife away from Alastor, only to end up accidentally scratching her cheek with the metal tip because Alastor had obviously managed to overpower her.
"Oh dear you're hurt. See this is why you shouldn't do such stupid things to yourself. At least it's only a scratch and not a deep cut" Sighs Alastor, pouting a little before he gently beginning to lick the wound clean, enjoying the taste of a mixture of (Y/N)'s tears and blood.
(Y/N) trembles gently at his actions while stammering. "W-Why are you doing t-this? I'm already y-your friend. T-this isn't what f-friends do." Alastor looks at her for a second, dumbstruck, before he let's her go completely and bursts out laughing. "You're really that naive? I thought you would have understood this by now. I want us to be more than friends silly" He says in between laughs.
"B-but... Then why'd you do all that?... " She asks, genuinely confused as she looked at him, mouth agape while staring at him, stunned.
He chuckles and gently leans in. "I don't think you get what I mean sweetie. I'll just have to show you" He smirks before gently placing his lips onto hers and kissing her lovingly. It was a soft and gently kiss since Alastor desperately wanted to show and prove to (Y/N) that he genuinely cared about and loved her.
(Y/N) was flabbergasted as she stared at him, before closing her eyes and gently kissing back out of pure reflex while enjoying the moment while it lasted.
(Y/N) quickly pulled away a few seconds after. "You stole my first kiss! " She yelled as she ran her finger over her lips, still processing what had just happened.
Alastor simply let out a happy chuckle as he put the knife back on the counter. "Seems weird that a gorgeous girl such as yourself had kept your first kiss for so long. Besides it's not like you were against it or anything. I'd say you rather enjoyed yourself. Besides it was my first time too. I've never liked someone the way I like you before" Alastor explained and wrapped his arms around (Y/N)'s waist and gently pulled her closer to him.
(Y/N) blushed as she fell onto him, avoiding looking up at his face since her face was as red as a tomato. "I was saving it for someone special alright! My soulmate. It would've been perfect" She grumbles shyly, clearly flustered.
"Aww c'mon. You know I love you. Besides life isn't a fairytale. A prince doesn't just come and sweep you off your feet. Heck the original stories were full of gore and deception. The later ones were adapted to make them seem more kid friendly" Alastor went on to yammer as he walks (Y/N) over to a couch and lays down, laying her on top of him and cuddling her.
(Y/N) blushes and snuggles close to him shyly. She still trusted him even after the stunt he'd pulled earlier. Besides he also really did seem to like her so she wasn't exactly opposed to their relationship.
"There's a good girl sweetheart. " Chuckled Alastor before flipping them over so that he was on top.
"Heck sleeping beauty was raped in the Grim Brothers version. If that's not messed up enough I don't know what is" He explains while gently placing kisses across her face and neck and smiling innocently.
(Y/N) blushes dark and giggles shyly." Yeah I know. Ariel didn't get her happy ending and the prince married someone else. That was sad" She says softly and looks up at him curiously as she noticed that he'd stopped kissing her.
Alastor looks down at her and chuckles. "So do you want to be my girlfriend or you'd rather I leave you like the prince did to Ariel? Girls can sometimes be a lot of work you know" He says as he grins jokingly.
"Don't joke about that. It's not funny. She dies sad and alone. Besides I'm not work. If you think I'm work then maybe I should just leave" Huffs (Y/N) angrily, not understanding that Alastor was merely joking as she pushed him off her and walked up to and opened the front before limping outside, away from the house.
Alastor shook his head. "She's so dramatic. I love her" He chuckled to himself before jumping off the couch and sprinting after her.