The Arcana x Reader Scenarios {Book One} {FINISHED}

When they think you are cheating on them

I have been thinking: I am planning to end this book with the scenario "When they propose to you" (which will be at chapter 199 since 200 will be to officially claim it's done and explain some stuff) and MAYBE (depending on how my life is at that moment and if I still have the passion/time to write more) write a second book, basically a continuation of this one about how you two are married, moving your stuff to his place/them moving their stuff to your place, how it is to be with each other 24/7, etc...

Does that sound like a good idea or like a bad one?

Requested by: Awesomeahahshokldm

Asra:

He trusts you, he knows you, you both are madly in love. But when he saw you sneaking out the shop and meeting someone in secret, the thought immediately came in his head, wondering if you are cheating. He tried to ignore it, think he is just becoming paranoid. So he tried to hang out with you, but you awkwardly declined and hurried away, which made him upset and wonder what he did wrong. A few days later, he couldn't handle it, he doesn't want to be in a relationship where he wonders the whole time if he's been cheated on while his lover cheats on him, so he confronted you when you tried to sneak out. You tried to tell him no, but he refused to take that answer, demanding you explain why you sneak out then. You could see he has been thinking about this for days and it was driving him insane, so you sighed and admitted you have been practicing magic in secret since he is such a good magician and you feel so useless aside him. That broke his heart that he made you feel useless, but he frowned and asked who that person is then. You couldn't help but chuckle as you said you got your friend to help so if you get injured while practicing, they can help you take care of the wound and whatever you broke. Asra stared for a few seconds, staring at your eyes, at you rbody language, making sure you aren't lying before he sighed and pulled you in a hug, mumbling he thought you were cheating with him with that friend before he pulled away to look you in the eyes, assuring you you aren't useless and you don't have to train in secret because he is more than happy to help you with any spells you have trouble with.

Nadia: 

She will not spy on you, trusting you are not cheating and she is simply misunderstanding. So she will politely ask you why you have been acting so secretive and always leaving for so long. When you shrugged and said you just feel like going out more, she forced a smile and said she understands that before letting you leave. What you said did not help to ease her mind, worrying you might actually be cheating, which she truly hopes is not the case. Luckily, a day later, you came home with a gift for her. She couldn't help but laugh as she asked if this is why you were so secretive. When you nod, she gave you a kiss, very happy you aren't cheating and were just making a gift for her.

Julian:

It was while he was drunk, the thought suddenly popped into his head. He knows you wouldn't do it, but he was drunk so he began thinking more and more of it till he began crying and saying he knew he wasn't good enough. When you arrived to drag him home since he has been here for hours, he jumped up and wrapped his arms around you, crying out you are so mean and he tried his best in the relationship and promises to try better. When you asked him what he's talking about, he pout as he mumbled your cheating before he began a rant why he understands since he wouldn't date someone as himself but cheating is so cruel. You couldn't help but slap the back of his head softly to shut him up, scolding him, telling him he's drunk and an idiot who overthinks every little thing and you would never do that. So you dragged him home, tucked him into bed. You had to cuddle him and pinky promise you will never cheat on him because he refused to sleep if you don't cuddle him and tell him you love him and pinky promise to never cheat.

Muriel:

This poor man overthinks a lot of things. If you are out for a long time, his mind will immediately say you are cheating and he should have known you would never go for someone as dumb and ugly as him. If you hang out with someone a lot, he will sigh and mumble that person is clearly better for you and he can never be so social and take you to fun places since he can't handle crowds and doesn't have the money to take you to fun places. So when you return home, will find Muriel cuddling Inanna, mumbling he knew he wasn't good enough. When you ask him what wrong is while worriedly stroking his hair, he will just look away from you and stuff his face in Inanna's fur, saying there is nothing wrong and he's simply having a bad day. He refuses to speak about this, worrying if he does, you will leave him, so he just keeps it bottled up and always uses the excuse he's having a bad day.

Portia:

She would never think that! She knows you wouldn't do such an awful thing, you two are too much in love to ever do such an awful thing. If she even goes near that thought, she will huff at herself and call herself dumb for even going to that thought. If you are gone for long and hanging out with someone a lot, she will just befriend the person and join in the hanging out, happy she is right that you aren't cheating but just hanging out with a friend. 

Lucio:

He will angrily rant nobody is good enough for you except him. He spied on you as you went to the market. When you were done talking to the baker, he rushed to the baker before demanding who the hell he is and what his relationship with you is. After the baker told him you just buy bread in the morning at his place almost every day, Lucio frowned before mumbling that's suspisous before he followed you again, only to not find you. When he turned, he let out a yelp as you stood in front of him, arms crossed. He awkwardly greeted you, saying the weather is nice today. When you asked him why he's following you, he awkwardly laughed, saying you will also laugh because this is silly. When he said he thought you were cheating on him, you stared at him before sighing and telling him he's an idiot. He huffed and said it's your fault for acting so distant suddenly and leaving so much. When you glared, he awwardly chuckled and said it's a silly misunderstanding so he will go home now.

Valerius:

The second he saw you hanging out with someone, being a little too friendly with them, he was quick to gulp down his wine before following you two. The second you left, he snatched the person's collar and asked them who the hell they are. After the person told him they are just a friend and you two never did anything, Valerius let go and said that's good to hear before back to the palace. When you looked at him, he just gave you a smile as if nothing happened before asking a servant to get him some wine.

Devil:

The person you were hanging out with too much went missing and was found hanging from the ceiling by chains, dangling upside down with third degree burns. When you heard, you angrily asked the Devil what the fuck he did that for. He tried to play innocent, claiming he didn't do it so you threw the chain against him, yelling that's his chain. He simply huffed and said you didn't have to cheat on him then. When you asked him what the fuck he's talking about now while rubbing your face in annoyance, wondering why you are dating a murderer. So he told you you have been acting distant to him as if you hate him suddenly while hanging out with that person so much and buying them things. When you glared and said you bought them gifts because it was an old friend who was visitng from another land so you were showing them around, he stared before mumbling you could have told him before he tortured the person. When you slapped him, he sighed and rubbed his jaw, claiming he only let you slap him because he deserved that. He didn't follow you when you stormed out the room, he completely understood why you were furious with him and decided to wait a few days before he goes and apologizes for torturing your old friend.