Scaled and Icy theories

Choker theories

Since people theorize so much about Scaled and Icy, especially about Shy Away, I decided to hop on the theory train and make some theories of my own!

These are just small theories I made up or thought of in my mind and I will also be sharing other people's theories.

×----×

So you know how people are saying Shy Away/Scaled and Icy is just Dema propaganda and people are saying Josh and Tyler either never escaped dema/got dragged back to dema, well I've seen may people making comparison's of these two images:

But the thing is if you have seen the music video (which I'm sure you have) you know it's Josh who is dragging the bag and who eventually turns Tyler to a bobble head/figurine.

But we all know this is Dema propaganda and well any TØP music video seen with Tyler and Josh they're helping each other out or just kinda existing with each other, neither of them were quite "the bad guy" or "the villian", the villian was always Blurryface and the bishops along with Nico.

So the question is why is Josh technically "the enemy" in this video?

Theory one:

That isn't Josh, and could be some sort of bot to be disguised like him to make sure Tyler stays, back to lure him into false security but Tyler finds out when he spots Josh reading this book in the music video-

- Tyler realizes it's not Josh and tries to run away only to fail and get captured and he hopes the real Josh will come and save him like in he does in Trench but by the sound of the lyrics he's giving up hope of being saved.

Theory two:

The Josh in the music video IS the actual Josh but just brainwashed by dema into becoming a follower of the bishops and is embracing the bishops religion of vialism and Tyler has found this out in the music video and tries to run away possibly with Trash (who I am guessing might be an important key to stop all of this) only to be caught by his brainwashed best friend and Tyler starts losing hope they'll escape Dema again.

Final theory:

Again, it IS Josh in the music video but the difference is Josh is pretending to accept the bishops lessons and pretending to be on the bishops side out of FEAR.

Because Tyler's blurryface is depression.

But Josh's blurryface is his anxiety.

Josh's blurryface is keeping him scared and complaint with the bishops and making him go against his friend due to fear of what they may have threatened to do to him or Tyler.

So Josh's anxiety is making him go against everything he stands for and believes in due to fear but he masks it with numbness or maybe he is numb to this now because of how much it overwhelmed him in the past it just doesn't effect him anymore due to the feeling just repeating itself to the point of exhaustion.

Tyler realizes this and has no hope for him or Josh ever getting out and is suffocating because he's suck in-between of the feeling of losing his grip on Josh and he's stuck in the walls of Dema. Tyler is giving up hope because if Josh lost hope he feels like there's no hope.

So they're technically stuck there because of Josh's fear to disobey the bishops.

×----×

Well, those were my Choker theories, I hope they weren't bad or already thought of but thank you so much for reading!

Yes I wrote this all at 3am.