Stuck Between Them

Chapter 9: I am going to kill her

Mature Content Warning

Max POV:

I entered the building I lightly banged my head on the wall. I kissed my sister, 'Stepsister'. Sarah's words rang in my mind.

Stepsister or not, this was one and done thing. It doesn't matter. Alex and I both agreed to forget about it. Generally when two people agree to forget about something that automatically means they won't do it again. Right!

I exited the elevator and cursed inwardly smacking my forehead with my hand. The fuck was I thinking, kissing her hand goodbye.

I rubbed my eyes to get a grip on myself. I unlocked the door, Sarah was sitting on the couch watching TV. She muted it and gestured me to come to sit with her like a little girl who wanted to hear a story.

"How did it go?"

"She took me to a nice restaurant. We had dinner, she told me how she got into the FBI, and I told her how I landed in NYU. We talked about how our past few years have been."

"boringgg", Sarah exhaled loudly.

"We went to River Park, we smoked."

"Wait you two smoked together. The fuck Max, That bitch is changing you. She has been back for two days and you are already doing things with her that you refused to do with me, What's next hmm.. You will be moving in with her."

"Nah.. Her apartment is way too plain for me... all grey and...."

Suddenly Sarah towered over me with her knees and arms on my either side.

"How do you know what color is her apartment."

I let out a nervous laugh. My feeling for Sarah hasn't changed but however I spin it, the fact cannot be changed that I kissed another girl. I have decided not to tell Sarah, what happened between me and Alex was uncalled for and is already forgotten.

"Actually, I visited her apartment."

"You, What............", she tugged on my shirt collar.

"We were at the park and she suddenly needed to Email something from her Laptop. So we went to her apartm...."

She didn't let me finish and crushed her lips with me. A spark went through me. As she kissed me I let out the sexual energy build up in me.

Sarah led by my hand into her bedroom, pulled back the covers on the bed, easily pulled off her dress, and lay down naked on it. I pulled off my clothes and lay next to her. She smiled at my hard cock standing out straight and immediately put her hand on it when I lay down next to her.

We kissed on our sides as I felt her wonderful breasts and she stroked my cock. Sarah nudged me onto my back and then perched over me guiding my cock into her with her hand. Her pussy was tight but well lubed with her juices. My cock was gripped firmly as it slid in easily. Sarah lay on top of me kissing me hungrily. I gripped both cheeks of her butt pulling her against me as she rocked on top.

She sat up and began squatting over my cock. Her full tits bounced as she moved up and down on me. She reached down and began to rub my cock as it went in and out as well as massaging her clit. Her demure look I'd seen earlier yielded to a lustful look as she was beginning to orgasm from her fingers as we fucked. Her fold began to spasm gripping my cock even tighter which triggered my orgasm. She again lay on top of me as I began spurting inside her still gripping our joined genitals. Thanks to God she was on birth control and we can do it bare.

She pulled me over on top of her telling me not to stop. She grabbed my cheeks strongly pressing with her nails. She had become a wild woman, begging me to keep going. "Fuck me! Keep going! Oh God, that's good. Fuck fuck fuck!"

We were fucking like two maniacs. I couldn't have stopped for anything at that point and kept pounding into her. Finally, I began to ejaculate inside her. She burst out in a guttural cry as she had an amazing orgasm. We collapsed together on the bed, rolled onto our sides while we were still joined, kissing each other madly until my cock softened and slipped out.

We drifted off as we lay together hugging blissfully.

--------------

Up until now, I wasn't planning on telling her about the kiss.

"Sarah."

"humm..." she answered.

We were still cuddling on my bed.

"Alex and I, we kissed."

She was silent and my heart stopped pumping blood.

"I am going to kill her and bury her in the central park.", she replied calmly.

"Before you go off to do that, you should deal with me first, I kissed her back."

"Tell me how it happened."

"she asked me what she said to me that night, I told her reluctantly, we hugged, she cried, I kissed her forehead to console her, she kissed my lips, everything went haywire from there. I told her this was spur of the moment thing and we won't talk about it ever again and she agreed."

"You have told me you loved her, I shouldn't be surprised that you kissed her back, I hold nothing against you but I'm still gonna beat her ass."

"You have come down from killing her to beating her ass, that's progress."

"Beating her ass to death."

"Sarah, please you won't say anything to her. What's done is done I don't want things to be awkward between us more than it already is."

"Ok but don't expect me to act nice around her, she kissed my boyfriend."

Sarah POV:

The voice: kill her. She kissed our mate.

Sarah: Rest assured, I won't let it slid. The bitch will pay.