Fearstreet imagines

An Old Crush- Cindy

Y/n used to have a crush on Cindy, you told her but she rejected you. What happens when you see each other at camp after five years. Will Cindy fall for you and will your feelings come back after seeing her again?
_________________________

Y/n POV

"Dude you know Cindy's gonna be here right?" My best friend Alice says from my bed.

"No shit. Alice I may not interact with her but I hear things. Which means I know she's a counselor." I say rolling my eyes, unpacking my things in my room. "Also where's Arnie? Is he here yet?"

"I don't know, he's supposed to be here at 6 I think. Anyways what are you going to do when you see her? It's been five fucking years y/n? Do you think she even remembers?" Alice says.

I unpack my last shirt and look over at her. "I'm going to try and ignore her. If we end up bumping into each other I'm going to be mature about it? I'm not some childish dick here Alice."

"Well you've heard she turned into some fucking pathetic pitch perfect girl then?" Alice asked standing up walking out.

"Alice! I really could care less. I doubt we'll even see each other she probably won't even recognize me. Also why should we care about how someone wants to live their life?" I say following after her. "Where are you going?"

"I'm a counselor... and I may or may not have signed you up as one." she mumbles.

"What!" I yell as Alice runs away from me. She goes into some building, I run after her. I run in and there's so many people in here. I recognize a couple but then again it has been five years.

"Y/n! Joan yells as she runs over and jumps on me. I catch her with a huge smile forgetting about what I came here for.

Joan and I got close some time after Cindy rejected me. I don't like her like that of course but she's my best friend along with Alice.

I let her go and realize the chatter has gone down. I look around and see that all eyes are on me. I hear things like,

"Woah is that really y/n?"

"She looks like a completely different person."

"I call dibs."

Kurt walks up to me as he eyes me up and down. "Well if it isn't y/n, and what is this?" He says pointing to my boobs. "Boobs? Y/n actually has boobs?" He says laughing.

I roll my eyes and flip him off. "Wait! How about you come to mine after?" He whispers.

"I bat for the other team. And I thought you have a rule for no Shadysiders?" I say loudly with my arms crossed.

He walks off back to the stage and starts talking. I hear him talking and he said that all the counselors are here. Cindy is here. She heard everything then. She has to remember me right? She heard my name just like everyone else. I began looking for her. After scanning the room I see her. But some dude has his arm around her. I shouldn't feel jealous, it's been five years. Five years! I observe her. She really has changed. She's wearing some fancy polo shirt with her hair looking fancy. She's still as beautiful as I remember. As I look back up to her, her eyes are staring at me. I quickly look away and walk out.

"Yo! Y/n!" I hear Arnie yell from beside me as I walk out of the counselor meeting I guess was happening.

He hugs me then asks where Alice is. "She's in that building, it's a counselors meeting." He walks there and I see someone walk out looking everywhere. Cindy. I start walking faster and faster to the dock on top of the water. I sit down and put my feet in not looking behind me to see if she was following.

I hear footsteps behind me and the dock move a little meaning someone is on here with me. I cringe knowing exactly who it is.

"Y/n?" Cindy's soft voice says.

I turn my body towards her. "Cindy." I say smiling. "Umm, how have you been?" I ask awkwardly.

"I'm...good." She says staling for a second. "You look different... I mean in a good way! But like—"

I cut her off. "It's fine, I get what you mean. I... dyed my hair and stuff that's probably why."

"Yeah..." she says not knowing what to say.

"Look let's just save us the awkwardness, we're good Cindy. Let's just act like it never happened. We're both counselors, we're gonna have to see each other." I say standing up. I'm about 5'8 so I have a few inches on her now. She used to be taller than me when we were younger and she'd make fun of me all the time.

"Okay good." She says smiling up at me. "You've gotten taller, wow." She says looking me up and down.

"Yeah, now it's my turn to make fun of you... shorty." I say smiling back at our memories.

Cindy laughs. "I'm sorry!" She pouts. "I didn't know I'd end up being the shorter one." She mumbles.

"I'm sorry.. what was that Cindy? I think you need to be a little louder." I say sarcastically.

She playfully shoves me forgetting I'm at the edge of the dock. I fall into the lake. I come up and see her with her hands on her mouth as she gasps. As I get up she keeps saying sorry. I give her a devilish smile as I start coming closer. She finally gets what I'm about to do.

"No! Y/n! No! Please!"

She tried to run away but only got a couple feet away. I threw her over my shoulder like a sack of potatoes running to the dock again.

"Put me down!" She says trying to protest.

I threw her in the lake but she had such a tight grip on me that I fell in with her. She came up gasping for air. "I can't swim!" She yells at me. I quickly bring her into my arms and she wraps her legs around me. I'm not going to lie butterflies were swarming in my stomach not that I'd ever admit it out loud.

We get out and she mean mugs me. "I got my shirt wet!" She says grumpily but in a cute way. You're washing this not me." She huffs out.

"Fine, deal. Come with me."

We walk to my cabin and I get one of my shirts for her. I throw it at her and she looks at me confused.

"Take your shirt off." I say.

"W-what." She says dumbfounded.

"Not like that silly. So I can wash your shirt. I'll look away." I say turning around.

After a few seconds I hear her voice. "Y/n... I'm stuck."

I turn around to see her wet shirt stuck to her. I can't help but let out a laugh. I walk over and she looks at me shyly. "Don't be embarrassed, it happens."

Our bodies are barley an inch apart. I take her shirt in my hands pulling it above her head. Once it's off we stare at each other. The tension is at an all time high right now. It's like a magnet is bringing me closer. I try to back away but it's almost impossible at this point. She's leaning in closer too. To my surprise she takes me and pushes me up against my door. Her lips are on mine in a quick motion. Her hands are on my waist. I come to my senses and kiss her back. The kiss gets heavy fast. Boobs are being grabbed, hands in each others hair. My knee makes it's way between her legs, Cindy let's out a moan. It's like all the tension from the last five years are being put into this kiss. My hands make their way to Cindy's ass and squeeze. Cindy's body arches into me as quickly as she leaves. In the blink of an eye she's gone and I'm left with her shirt.
_________________________

Should I make a part 2? I have a couple imagines from requests so I'll be working on those also!