Not who I thought (Tyler galpin x reader)

17. wednesday

*15 minutes later* As I sat on the bathroom floor with tear stains on my face there was a knock on the bathroom door. I stood up and opened the door seeing Wednesday. "Can I help you?" I quickly wiped my face off. She examined my face for a moment before speaking. "You were crying, why?" She furrowed her brows a bit.

"Just stuff. Did you need something?" I smiled. "Yes." She stood there not saying anything. "So...?" I cocked a brow. "I find it awfully strange that there was a monster in the woods, but mrs. Thornhill isn't a Hyde and completely "normal"" she lifted her chin up.

I stared at her blankly for a moment. "So what does that have to do with me?" I gave a bit of an attitude. "I have a feeling your hiding something." She said and with that she walked away. I rolled my eyes after she closed the door and walked over to my bed. I laid down and started to look around.

This is when I took in the fact that Enid had left. She left. No goodbye, or are you ok... nothing.

*the next day*

I walked up to Tyler's front door and knocked. The door opened a few moments later and I saw Tyler smiling at me. "Hey" he stepped to the side and let me in. "I missed you" he smiled, closing the door in the process. "Shut up, i just saw you the other day." I joked. His smile grew as he hugged me. I hugged him back wrapping my arms around his torso.

"Your dads not here, still?" I mumbled against his t-shirt. "Nope. He hasn't texted me either, but it's fine he is always like this." He quickly brushed it off. I pulled away looking at him with furrowed brows. "Tyler is it really fine?" I raised my brows already knowing the answer. "I guess it's not fine I'm just used to it by now. It's been this way since my mom..."

I nodded. "You wanna go upstairs? Or sit here and talk about my dad?" He smirked. I smiled holding his hand and rushing up the stairs. Once we were in his room I took my shoes off. I got my sweater off, setting it on the chair. Tyler was already sat on his bed. "How was your day?" He said as I plopped down next to him. "Amazing." I said sarcastically. He sighed. "What's wrong?" He looked at me.

"Well Wednesday thinks I'm hiding something about the murders in the woods. Which to be fair I am. But I don't get how she knows." I laid down on my back. Tyler leaned down next to me. "She probably won't find out." He laughed. I glared at him. "Exactly, PROBABLY." I raised my brows. His arm went around my waist and he leaned his head against my chest. "It'll work out, trust me." He looked up at me.

"How was your day?" I asked changing the subject. "Oh. It was spontaneous!" He said sarcastically. "I love sitting home doing nothing!" He smiled. "Hey. I actually love staying home and doing nothing." I said. "I know you do. Your depressing ass room says a lot about you." He joked. "We don't talkkkk about thatttt" I smiled pushing at his face.

We both laughed for a moment before he moved towards my face crawling over me. I smiled at him. He gently brushed his lips against mine before kissing me. I closed my eyes enjoying the moment. His lips moved softly against mine, my hands went to his shoulders gently moving up to his hair. i pulled away and sat up. tyler followed my movements.

"what's wrong?" he asked furrowing his eyebrows. "i don't think i can do... it, right now i'm sorry" i said. "no dont be sorry" he smiled. "we don't need to do... it, everytime." he mocked me. i smiled and kissed his nose. "how about we watch a movie?" he nodded towards his tv. "gladly! but i pick." i said, jokingly giving him a glare.

"the way i know exactly what genre your gonna pick too." he cocked a brow and laid down on his back. i smiled to myself excitedly as i grabbed his remote. i go on netflix and click on "search" i type in "horror" and i look at tyler with a smirk. he shook his head at me. "knew it." he mumbled.

i scrolled through it and put on "texas chainsaw massacre 2022" i've never seen this one so might as well.

*during the movie*

"THAT DOESNT EVEN MAKE SENSE HOW DOES BRO JUST SNAP HIS ARM WITH ONE HAND?!" i shouted with my brows furrowed. "he's just super strong i guess." tyler shrugged as we laid together. "bullshit." i glared at him.

a few minutes later... "JESUS FUCKING CHRIST!!" i sat up and looked at tyler. "i mean how fucking stupid can she be. this lady must be so dumb. how do you not wait till you know FOR SURE that he leaves and try to escape out of the window. she would have been alive if she didn't move and waited till he left." i crossed my arms.

tyler laughed at my annoyance by this movie. "y/n, she is panicking she's in fight or flight mode right now." he said. i turned to him once again. "no excuses, she could've waited to 'fly' when she knew for sure that he left." i let myself fall back on the bed.

"you chose this movie y/n..." tyler teased. "well if i knew it was gonna be stupid i wouldn't have." i laughed and reached for the remote, clicking off of the movie. "new idea!" i smiled. "different movie!" i looked at tyler excitedly.

(sorry i haven't updated ✋😭 i've been a little too mentally i'll lately...)