Not who I thought (Tyler galpin x reader)

12. job well done

*1 hour later*

I felt Tyler's arm lift off of me and I turned to look at him. "You ok?" I asked. He was looking at his phone. "Laurel wants me to meet her..." he said with a slightly nervous expression. I sat up still being careful with my leg. "When?" I furrowed my brows. Tyler looked at me and sighed. "Right now." He rolled his eyes and let out a deep breath. "Well you have to go!" I said as he looked at me once again.

"I know I know. But I don't want to." His tongue poked at his cheek in annoyance. "Tyler you have to... but maybe once you go there we can expose her." I smirked. Tyler sat up and smiled. "Shit your right... I have an idea. Get principal weems to the cave. As soon as possible." He stood up off the bed in a rush. I smiled. He turned to me and leaned down, kissing me gently. "Ok you got to go!" I laughed.

"Right right-" Tyler said running out of the door. I got off the bed. "Shit-" I huffed at the pain in my leg. "Fuck it." I walked over to the door, each step I took made my leg feel like it was getting stabbed repeatedly but I tried my best to ignore it. I walked to principal weems office and saw the door already opened. "Principal weems!" I called out in a hurry. "Y/n? What can I do for you?" She leaned over her desk as I approached her.

"You shouldn't be out of bed mrs. Y/l/n. It will make your leg worse!" She said genuinely worried. "Listen. I know who's been killing in the woods- i need to take you to her lair. It's in the woods and we should bring the sherif!" I explained quickly. "Y/n-" she said about to dismiss me. "Please! This will solve everything! Its not a student! It's actually a normie." I furrowed my brows impatiently.

She thought for a moment before standing up. "Very well then. Let's go." She smiled.

*at the woods*

"Are you sure it's around here?" The sherif asked as he looked around. "Yes it's just up that way!" I pointed ahead. As me, weems, the sherif, and some other officers approached the now burned down cave we saw mrs. Thornhill with a knife in her hand. I gasped a bit when I saw Tyler tied to a tree. "Hey! Hold it right there!" The sherif yelled as he approached with his gun in hand aswell as the other officers behind him. They ran up and I walked quickly to Tyler. I looked to see a dismembered body infront of laurel and my brows raised in shock.

"How did you do it?" I whispered to Tyler as I untied him from the tree. "I killed that guy... did what I was supposed to. Then I just made her really mad at me. And she tied me up. She said she was gonna "get me under control." So she grabbed her knife and now here we are." He looked at me as he moved away from the tree. The ropes falling as he faced me now. I smiled at him. "Good job tyler." I smiled.

We looked over to see the officers taking Thornhill/Laurel away. The sherif approached and hugged Tyler tight. "Son, what the hell happened?" He pulled away resting his hands on Tyler's shoulders. Me and principal weems stood near them listening to the conversation. "I was walking to work and she knocked me out." He said putting his hand up to a small cut on his head I had ent noticed before.

"I woke up and I was tied to that tree. And the- the dead body-" fake tears slid down his face. "She said I was next- I didn't know what to do dad..." he finished. I was impressed by his lying skills. If I didn't know any better I would've believed he was actually attacked by her.

They hugged again. "I'm glad your safe now son." He mumbled to tyler. I smiled at the sweet sight. Once they pulled away the sherif looked at me. "So. How did you know she was behind all this?" He furrowed his brows. "Me and Wednesday have been trying to figure it out. And I found out who I thought was mrs. Thornhill was actually a woman named laurel gates."

Weems had a shocked expression. "She was trying to bring her dead relative back to get rid of our school, specifically the student inside." I explained. "Jesus." The sherif sighed. "We should all head back now. Y/n especially you. Your leg isn't well and you need to let it heal." Weems said and started walking. Unexpectedly tyler hugged me. I rested my head on his shoulder and hugged him back. I looked at the sherif who looked a bit confused.

As Tyler pulled away he kissed me, it caught me by surprise. And the sherif too. He pulled away and smiled at me. "Tyler?" The sherif questioned. Tyler looked at him. "Oh right, dad..." he wrapped his hand around my waist and pulled me close to his side. "This is y/n. My girlfriend." He smiled widely at his dad. His dad smiled. "Nice to meet you y/n." The sherif nodded his head.

"Nice to meet you too." I said lowkey feeling awkward. The fact he just- kissed me- infront of his dad- like it was nothing????? I mean I'm not complaining... BUT STILL. "Let's go." Tyler said and took my hand in his. Our fingers intertwined as we walked back.

"I can't wait to tell Wednesday about this. Maybe she will actually smile." I smiled to myself. "And Enid! I can't wait to tell her." I looked at Tyler who was smiling. "Yea, tell them all about my traumatizing day." He looked at me. "You survived didn't you?" I raised my brows. "Yes I did." He smirked and looked ahead. (We gotta say all this cause sherif still there 💀)

(A/n: 😝 there may be... smut... in the next chapter... MAYBE....)