Ben drowned X reader

Planning

*Exactly 40 minutes later, Jeff had finished placing the new window. After handing Masky, Toby, and Hoodie the remaining materials Jeff decided to ask them what or how he should deliver the upcoming talk later that day. However, Jeff had a feeling that they weren't going to give him much help on the topic.*

Jeff: Come on Masky! Out of the three of you, there should be some advice or a better understanding of this whole atmosphere/love situation between a human and creepypasta! You must have seen more than once this type of problem to at least give me some information on how to break the news a little bit gently... Or else Ben's gonna come after me for having to scare the girl from him! *He says while tugging Masky by the shoulders*

Masky: *sighs* You mean the fact that me, Toby, and Hoodie have seen countless fangirls being killed, erasing their memories, or being used as part of Slenderman's experiments then yes. But seeing one of our kind falling in love with a human is far from what either of us knows. There are some cases where one had caught feelings but not permanently. The longest relationship I know that Slenderman had told me and Hoodie was about 3 years only. But in time someone starts to lose interest or feelings for the other one, leading to Slenderman having to erase the memories of either one person or both.

Hoodie:... Slenderman told us but not Toby because he can't keep a secret. We know the names of the Creepypastas that had been in that situation before, but we can't say anything since we had to get marked by Slenderman's symbol again to keep our mouths shut.

Toby: Why do I-I-I feel like I should be taking that as an insult? A-A-Anyway, why ask for advice over love between a human? *Gasps* Did you f-f-fall in love with a human girl Jeff?! It's the end of the world!

Jeff: *Yanks Toby by the collar of his shirt* I did not fall in love you damn ticking time bomb! It just so happens that Ben is! That's why he was acting all glitchy and insane yesterday when I was "resting" in my room!

Masky: Toby for crying out loud, you were in the mansion yesterday practicing throwing your hatchets outside the forest like usual. Don't tell me you didn't see all the lights in each room turning off and on by themselves now and then. Didn't you see the cables and wires coming to life on their own whenever Ben walked around? Or being randomly shocked by every electronic or technology that was within Ben's distance?

Toby: LOL you do realize that I can't feel anything, I am pure n-n-numbness. All I know is that I saw a lot of p-p-puncture marks all over my body when I took a shower. O-O-Oh, and I did see some of the guys being dragged left and right once I got back inside, only I thought it was Slenderman "teaching" e-e-everyone a lesson about taking their work seriously. But I was unable to see the cables or wires with my goggles covered in dried b-b-blood from my last mission.

Hoodie:...You don't say.

Jeff: Anyway I need... some sort of advice on how should I bring up the news to the girl. I am not trying to threaten or force her to forget about Ben. It's just... how should I put it, Ben is very much smitten with her. But I think it's just him loving how she looks, not beauty or physical features just an attraction. He did have that gaze of being love-struck, and she did say that he went disguised as a new boy in her high school.

Masky: All that to be with her? Not what I expected out of Ben, to be honest. But I gotta hand it to elf boy, he is taking it slow to win the girl's heart. Normally a Creepypasta would kidnap, kill, stalk, or do more violent actions to take the one they fell for. Never thought Ben was the patient type when it came to girls, he seemed more like the obsessed type. No matter, I would recommend you explain the situation she is getting in because a Creepypasta is unstable to be with like it is with a normal male.

What the consequences would be whenever Ben's mood loses control. How easily his head can be clouded with anger, vengeance, or any other type of negative emotion causing him to lose his sanity.

*As Masky continues giving Jeff a long piece of advice about how he should "help" you, Hoodie decides to join in the conversation before it ends.*

Hoodie: But where are you guys going? Didn't Slenderman tell you to take her somewhere to make up for the trouble since she's a special case?

Jeff: Right, so about that we are heading to the mall in a bit. I told Y/n that I would be buying her whatever she wanted since Slenderman gave me cash, as "condolences" for the trouble I caused her.

Masky: Right so you might as well get going now since we are about to be on our way, the three of us got our own tasks Slender had given us for the next few weeks. Technically, he decided to give us double the work since you'll be busy bringing more test subjects to the lab.

Jeff: Is it because Eyeless Jack and the others have trouble keeping the subjects alive?

 Toby: Nope! It's be-be-because they don't knock them o-o-out well enough like you. 

Masky: Basically, the subjects wake up too early or die before the process begins. And since you "surprisingly" time the moment to knock subjects just right, Slenderman had decided you are far more reliable then the rest of them. Personally I and Hoodie would prefer taking your task but orders are orders.

Jeff: Thanks for the praises, however I gotta get going. The quicker I get it over with the better. Damn it, not good with feelings let alone reading emotions. 

Hoodie: Ah wait... You need these... *Shakes a bottle container with black pills* Slenderman told us to give them to you,  to avoid standing out in public. 

Jeff: *Grabs the container while taking out one pill, inspecting the drug* Is this the new creation Slender wanted me to have? Is it gonna kill my intestines?

Hoodie: No, it's meant to change your appearance, that way you would look like your previous self. Before you turned into...

Jeff: ...Ah, I see... Well I'll see you guys I have to go back now, thanks fellas.

Masky: Good luck Jeff. 

As Jeff walks back inside the three proxies began taking their time to head back to the mansion. Taking the broken glass shards in a bucket as well as the tools, the three look back as time goes on.