[Harry Potter] Hogwarts Mystery Beyond: Summer Harem Reunion

Tropical Lost (Male Reader x Chiara Lobosca & Jules Egwu x Liz Tuttle)

"Hey MC... don't you feel like something is... wrong?" Ben asks sitting across from me at the breakfast hall-

I lounge back in my chair, "What do you mean?"

Ben then glances over at Penny and Tulip who are sitting on either side of me, my blonde girlfriend using a fork to feed me an egg while the redhead prankster kisses my right cheek-

The blonde obliviator then aggressively replies,
"I'm saying that you don't find it odd that this curse that's affecting you hasn't done anything bad?"

I ponder for a brief second until Tulip nibbles on my neck,
"Nope."

As Ben shakes his head in frustration, Merula, sitting nearby casually comments,
"Yeah, I tried to warn him Copper- he's a lost cause."

Tulip pulls back from me a little and asks,
"Since Sikander hasn't given his daily announcement yet, why don't we ask each other about a sensitive topic."

Ben and I nod nonchalantly, while Penny hesitantly adds,
"Umm- yeah! Depends on the subject, I suppose."

The mischievous half-Turkish witch thinks for a full minute until she grins and responds,
"I've been noticing a certain person sitting in this group rather distracted whenever Professor Sinestra comes by."

Immediately Ben, Penny and Tulip turn towards me and I sheepishly fluster,
"What-? I- well... ok so I'm the only one who sees how attractive she is?"

Penny flashes me a look which pretty much confirms she's not down with inviting older witches to our 'openness' while Tulip smirks,

"I can kinda see what you mean... but what about the rest of you? Any staff at Hogwarts catch your eye?"

Ben scratches the back of his neck nervously until Penny whispers,
"Ok... I may have had a small crush on Snape back in my third year- I just used to imagine him being nicer would have made him the perfect Potions Master-"

Ben and I look rather stunned while Tulip snorts,
"That's wicked- I reckon Corey probably has written a story about that exact kind of thing-"

Penny then turns her head, "Corey's writing what?"

Before Tulip can explain Corey's provocative collection of stories, Ben opens up muttering,
"I... used to like Septima Vector... the Arithmancy Professor."

I give Ben a confused stare, "I thought Professor Babbling was the Arithmancy Professor."

Penny sighs in a tired voice, "She's the Ancient Runes Professor, MC..."

Tulip then casually says, "As for me, I used to have a thing for Peeves the Poltergeist-"

"WHAT-?!" Ben, Penny and I exclaim at the same time-