Tainted Love ||Stu Macher||

Chapter 1: Lilly Loomis

You've got the devil
In your eyes
You went
And took me by surprise

"Lilly! Come on! Dinner's ready!" Billy calls to his twin sister upstairs where she was painting in her bedroom.

Lilly sighs as she puts down her paintbrush and wipes her hands on her cleaning rag before heading downstairs.

She walks into the kitchen where Mister and Missus Loomis are at the table, her mother setting out plates and her father in his chair.

Billy comes out of the kitchen, holding a plate of wings.

Lilly smiles, "Is it pizza and wings night?"

Missus Loomis laughs, "Yes, Lillian. Come, sit."

Lilly skips over to the table before sitting down next to her father.

"Oh, my friend, Stu, is gonna come over for dinner tonight," Billy says to his family as he brings out one more plate.

The doorbell rings, "I'll get it." Lilly says as she gets up from her seat and walks over to the door.

Stu stuffs his hands in his pockets as he waits on the other side of the door. It opens and he freezes in his spot in awe.

He did not expect this beautiful girl to answer the door. Her hair was sleeked back into a ponytail, she was wearing black and white striped pajamas, and her arms and hands were covered in paint.

"Uh, hi." Lilly giggles at Stu's silence.

Stu shakes his head, "Sorry. Hi, I'm Stu Macher."

Lilly smiles, "Lilly Loomis. Billy's twin."

"Billy and Lilly?" Stu chuckles as he steps inside. "Cute. He never told me he had a twin sister."

"That's because she's a bitch who hits on my friends." Billy's voice comes through as he comes up behind Lilly.

Lilly smiles at Stu, "Well, how can I not when your friends are as cute as this."

Stu smirks, "I'd like to think I am."

Billy yanks him away into the dining room before Lilly can say anything else. She rolls her eyes as she walks into the kitchen and grabs a soda.

Stu looks over and watches as Lilly bends over to grab the soda from the fridge. He bites his lip as he feels his pants become tight.

"Stop." Billy smacks his chest, "Come on, man. That's my sister."

Lilly walks back into the dining room, she sets her soda down before taking her place back next to her father. And across from Stu and Billy.

"So, Stu. May I ask what your plans are this weekend?" Missus Loomis asks.

Stu smiles, "Nothing. My parents are going out of town so it'll just be Billy and I at my house this weekend." He says.

We all dig into the food, Stu looks at Lilly and winks. She smirks as she scoots in her chair and runs her foot up his leg, making him jump.

Billy looks at him in confusion, "You okay, man?"

"Yeah, I'm fine. Sorry." Stu chuckles.

Lilly giggles under her breath as her foot moves up further. She rubs his thigh with her toes before pulling away, making him let out a breath.

"Sorry to cut this short but I have to go." Mister Loomis says as he wipes his mouth with a napkin. "I have some things I gotta do at the office."

"Okay. See you later, honey." Missus Loomis says as he gives a smile before leaving out the door. "So, Billy. Maybe you can take Lilly with you, she could use a night out."

"Absolutely. My friend Sidney could use some company." Stu replies before Billy can protest.

"I'd love to," Lilly says as she and Stu share a sly smirk.

~*~

God, why does Billy always get such hot friends? Lilly thought to herself as she lay in bed that night.

For about 25 minutes now, she tossed and turned trying to go to sleep. She couldn't stop thinking about Stu.

Just from being across him all evening, she felt like jumping across the table and having him take her right there.

"Goddamn, his stupid hot face!" She whispers harshly into the darkness of her room.

She huffs in annoyance as she lies on her back, her mind filling with dirty thoughts about Stu. Sighing, she runs her hands on her body. One of her hands ran down to her already wet heat and the other wrapped around her breast.

Her hand slips inside her pj shorts and panties before she runs two fingers over her clit. She gasps as she rubs faster, imagining it was Stu's fingers making her cum.

Letting out a moan, Lilly moves her fingers to her eager entrance before dipping one then two.

She starts to thrust them at a steady pace, "Stu. Fuck." She whines, careful not to wake her family.

Her back arches, and she clenches around her fingers as she's grasping her peak. She removes her hand from her breast and wraps it around her throat before squeezing with just enough pressure to cut her airway a little.

She tenses and releases on her fingers, letting out a quiet moan, thinking about Stu the whole time.

Satisfied, she flopped down against her bed and fell into a deep sleep.