I can't lie, I just wish I never met you in the first place
Damn, why you had to come and kiss me in the first place?
Damn, why we had to even mix it in the first place?
Damn, then we went ahead and slid into third base
And I wish I never ever met you in the first placeAfter a good four days at Stu's cabin, Lilly was back to school in New York with Stu saying that he even had a small apartment not far from her campus.
~Flashback~
"Are you seriously telling me, you're risking getting caught by campus security and possibly by police to 'keep an eye on me'?" Lilly rolls her eyes as she leans her head back against the couch, "How stupid does that sound, Stuart?"
Stu comes up behind her, holding two bowls of vanilla ice cream with chocolate syrup drizzle on top. "It's not stupid. We managed to stay under the radar for a whole year." He hands her a bowl before walking around the couch and sitting down next to her.
"You say that like we're professional serial killers." Lilly scoffs as she takes a bite of the ice cream before she points at the tv, "Look, see? Jeffery Dahmer evaded the cops for a while before they actually traced it back to him." She points to the documentary in front of him, "He was good but they still caught him."
"Well, I'm not saying we have to be perfect." Stu shrugs, "You don't have to change but I do." He sighs as he leans over and kisses her cheek. "I'll figure something out, baby. I always do."
~End Flashback~
Ever since then, he drove Lilly home and she's yet to hear from him in the past three days that she's been back.
Jason had yet to be back, too. That got Lilly thinking, 'what could he possibly be doing in Kansas City that would take him almost two weeks to do'? Of course, she instantly thought the worst.
He's cheating on me. That's the only explianation for him disappearing. That and not answering my calls or texts.
Lilly looks at the knife next to the cutting board that she was using while preparing for dinner, the blade sending a menacing wink as the light reflects against it. Almost as if it's beckoning her to use it and not for cooking purposes.
Her heart beats loudly as it's fueled by her anger and hurt at the possiblity that Jason could be seeing someone other than her.
But then it becomes hurt and confusion as she remembers everything that she's done with Stu not too long ago. What he said to her, what she said to him.
~Flashback~
Stu pulls away from her neck, looking at her with lust and love. "I've missed you so much, baby." He groans before continuing, "I've missed how you taste, how you feel, those noises you make. Everything, Lills." He leans down and presses his lips to hers.
Lilly lets out muffled moans against his lips, she couldn't deny it anymore. She missed him like crazy and here he was, fucking her with no mercy just like he used to. She had to tell him.
"I missed you, too." She mumbles against his lips, "I-- fuck! I've missed this."
~End~
![](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/365668032-144-k196311.jpg)
YOU ARE READING
Tainted Love ||Stu Macher||
FanfictionLillian (Lilly) Loomis is the twin sister of Billy Loomis. His badass other half, who he'll do anything for can't get caught in the crossfire of what her brother has planned. But that all comes crashing down when she ends up dating his best friend...