Tainted Love ||Stu Macher||

Chapter 2: What's Your Record?

Right now, I'm shameless
Screaming my lungs out for you
Not afraid to face it
I need you more than I want to

Three days later, it was finally Saturday. And that meant, it was the day of the get-together at Stu's. Lilly was excited to meet the girl known as Sidney.

But of course, she was more excited to see Stu and his house. From what Billy's said, it was big.

"Lilly! Did you finish packing?" Billy shouts for his other half.

"Yes. Coming down." Lilly calls back as she grabs her backpack and walks downstairs where Billy is waiting.

"Alright, Mom. We'll be back tomorrow." Billy calls just as Stu pulls up in his car.

They walk outside and to his car, "'Sup, twins!" Stu laughs.

They get into his car before he drives off towards his house, "So, Sidney should be there any minute. I think you'll like her, Lilly. You guys seem like you'd get along great."

Lilly shrugs, "I give everybody a chance." She reaches into her backpack and smiles as she pulls out her secret stash.

They arrive at Stu's house before Lilly speaks up, "Hey, boys." They turn to her before she holds up her baggie of weed. "You guys wanna have some fun?"

Both boys' eyes widen at the substance, "Where the fuck did you get that?" Billy sighs in disappointment.

"My friend Leo still sells. What do you say, guys?" Lilly asks, a wide smirk on her face.

Stu shrugs, "What the hell. I'm in."

Billy sighs, "Fine. Sure."

Lilly laughs in victory as they get out of the car, and she freezes in awe of Stu's house. Not a house, more like a mansion.

"You must have loads of parties going on all the time," Lilly says.

Stu chuckles, "Yeah, sometimes. My parents are always out of town so it's pretty much just me."

Walking inside, Lilly softly chuckles as she looks around at the pictures and decor. They all walk into the living room where Stu has laid out a bunch of snacks on the coffee table.

"Let's spark one up," Billy says as he sets his bag down and sits on the couch while Stu sits on the floor next to the coffee table.

Lilly sits in front of Stu and takes out a pre-rolled joint she had done before coming. Bringing it to her lips, she takes a lighter and sparks it up as she takes a hit from it.

She inhales and passes it to Stu who winks at her as he takes the joint from her and takes a hit himself.

Letting the smoke out, Lilly starts to cough. She turns her head away as she coughs into her arm.

Stu chuckles as he lets the smoke out and passes it to Billy. "Damn, that's some good shit."

Billy coughs, "Yeah, sis. Where does your friend get this stuff?"

Lilly giggles after recovering from her coughing fit, "He grows it himself."

The doorbell rings, Stu smiles as he gets up from his seat on the floor. "That must be Sidney."

Lilly's eyes follow him as he walks over to the door, silently letting out a swooning sigh.

"Stop it," Billy says as he takes another hit. "I know you just wanna get in his pants."

Lilly laughs, "Well, have you seen him? Have you ever seen what he's got beneath those clothes?"

Billy chokes on the smoke, "No! And I never want to, either!"

Lilly gets lost in thought, about him.

Lilly pants as Stu pushes her up against the wall, his lips pressing feverish kisses against her lips. His hands ran down to her ass and squeezed hard.

Stu groans as Lilly's hands tangle in his hair and tug. His hands leave her ass as they pin her hands above her head before turning her to face the wall.

He rapidly pulls down his pants before removing Lilly's shorts and panties. Spitting in his hand, Stu lubricates his length and slides himself into her.

"Lilly," Stu says.

"Hey, Lilly."

Wait, what?

Lilly is pulled out of her thoughts by Billy calling her name. She shakes her head and finds Stu and Sidney standing in front of them.

"Lilly, this is my friend, Sidney. Sid, this is Lilly, Billy's twin sister." Stu introduces as they sit down.

~*~

A few hours later, everyone, except Sidney, was high out of their minds. Giggling and saying stupid shit that makes them laugh.

Stu and Lilly sit on the couch together while Billy and Sidney sit in front of the TV, next to the coffee table. Billy is too busy talking to Sidney to notice his sister flirting with his best friend.

"So, what's your record?" Stu asks as he leans his head against his hand on the back of the couch.

"On what?" Lilly replies.

"How many times you've cum in one night. How many times you've done it in one night." Stu says, his voice is husky and his eyes beet red.

Lilly is not one to blush but with Stu, it just happens. "Well, I've never really had good luck in the guy department so my records are 3 and 2."

Stu snickers, "Fuck, that's some bad luck. Mine's 5." Lilly looks at him with wide eyes. "One night, five times." He smirks.

Lilly involuntarily clenches her thighs together at the thought of Stu emptying his load only to just keep going.

"You sure you're not lying?" Lilly teases as she scoots closer to him. She runs a finger down his neck and hooks onto his chain around him.

Stu shivers and bites his lip, "You sure you're not lying to try and entice me?"

Lilly softly giggles, "Touchè."

Billy turns to see how close they are, "Hey! Back off." He says to them, mostly Lilly.

Lilly sighs in disappointment as she moves away from Stu, glaring at her brother.

Billy shakes his head, "Hey, Stu. Lend me the keys. Sid and I are gonna go pick up some more beer."

Stu tosses his keys to him, "Wanna come?" He asks.

"Nah, I'ma hang back," Stu replies.

Billy looks to his sister who shakes her head, "I'm okay. Just bring me back a candy bar."

"Alright. We'll be back. But, I'm warning you. Touch my sister, I'll kill you." Billy says as he walks out with Sidney.

When she hears the car drive away, she quickly straddles Stu and presses her lips to his. He moans in surprise as his hands rest on her hips.

Lilly pulls away and slides down to her knees in front of Stu's hardened length over his jeans.