MLP EG: Rainbow Rocks Sundown Glare x Reader

The Failed Attempt

Previously on MLP EG Rainbow Rocks...

"And I've got some bad news about those new boys and I've also got some news about what happened to Y/n." Dusk stated, sounding worried as he looked at me.

.

.

.

Y/n POV

We all go to Sugarcube Corner for a drink and a chat. Dusk and Rarity are seated on a couch, Sundown and I on one of its arms, Applejack/Fluttershy/Rainbow in chairs, Applejack sitting backwards on hers and Spike on Fluttershy's lap, Pinkie bringing over a couple of drinks. On the next line, she sits down next to Dusk and gives her one, keeping the other-a chocolate milkshake-for herself. Rainbow already has a beverage of her own, and a cup of tea sits before Rarity.

"Oh, I do hate that you've had to return in a time of crisis. We have so much catching up to do!" Rarity exclaimed.

"For starters...a certain blue-haired guitar player was just askin' about his best friend." I stated.

"Flash was asking about me? I've missed him too after a long time." Dusk stated.

"Perhaps you could give us just the slightest bit of gossip from your world?" Rarity asked.

He's got an official title now. The Prince of Friendship!" Spike announced.

"Wow, that's really impressive. Guess you really were Princess Celestia's prize pupil." Sundown said.

"He's even got his own castle." Spike stated.

Rarity leans toward Dusk with gusto, startling said Prince into spilling his drink on himself.

"A castle?!? You have your own castle?!? Uh...ooh, uh, lovely." Rarity said, calming herself and cleaning Dusk's shirt.

"What's new here? I mean, besides your school becoming the target of dangerous magical creatures from Equestria." Dusk stated.

"Speaking of which, you still haven't told me the new you found out about me." I stated.

"Oh, right...Y/n...this is a little hard to say, but...you're a siren from Equestria." Dusk said and my jaw hit the floor.

"I can't be a siren...I was born and raised here. How could I be from Equestria?" I asked.

"Your real name is S/n Amarante(which means unfading or everlasting love)and when you were sent here from Equestria, you lost all memory of who you were and your magic along with it." Dusk said.

I felt my world crumbling around me; my life has been lie, all of it.

"So, everything I've known...has been a lie? Do my parents or brothers(you and Flash have a younger brother named First Base, I know weird name)know about this? Have they been keeping me in the dark? When were they going to tell me?!" I exclaimed, when Sundown kissed me and I immediately calmed down.

"There you go, calm down, babe; one question at time, okay?" Sundown asked and I nodded.

"I know this must be hard to understand and I would understand if you would want some time to yourself." Dusk said and I nodded as I got up.

"That's really sweet, Dusk and thank you. I'll be back after I comprehend what I was just told." I said as I walked off.

Dusk Shine POV

I watched as Y/n left and I felt bad for pouring all that on her out of nowhere.

"Yeah, so that isn't exactly the only strange thing that's happened since you left." Rainbow Dash stated.