It's strange how clarity sneaks up on you in the middle of your worst moments, when everything you've built lies shattered at your feet—football, friendships, my relationship with Ava—all broken, scattered into pieces I can no longer pretend to hold together. For so long, I had convinced myself, and everyone else, that I could manage it all. That I could keep juggling the expectations, the lies, and the truth I refused to face. But the more I tried, the more everything unraveled. And now, here I was, standing in the ruins of my life, forced to confront the one thing I'd been avoiding: myself.
There wasn't any fixing this. No magical solution, no going back to being the star quarterback, the perfect boyfriend, the son who could do no wrong. That version of me—if he ever really existed—was gone. For so long, I wore that mask so well that I started to believe in it. But deep down, I knew. The cracks had always been there, small at first, but widening over time until the pressure became unbearable. I had ignored them, convinced that pushing through the pressure, soldiering on, was the only way to survive.
But survival wasn't enough anymore.
I wasn't here for redemption. This wasn't about getting Coach to put me back on the field or fixing things with Ava. This was about something far bigger—facing the truth about who I really was. It was about tearing down the walls I'd built around myself, admitting the things I'd buried so deep inside that they'd almost destroyed me.
Jason had been on my mind constantly since that day at the coffee shop. He'd been the one person who really listened, who saw past the mess I had made and didn't judge me for it. The way he had sat there, calm and patient, had stirred something inside me—a small, fragile hope that maybe, just maybe, I could be honest. With him. With myself.
But that hope terrified me. What would happen when I laid everything bare? When I admitted to Jason how I felt? Would he walk away, say this was too much, too complicated? That fear gnawed at me, but I knew I couldn't keep hiding. I owed it to him, to myself, to lay everything out in the open.
Campus felt eerily quiet as I walked toward Jason's dorm. The late afternoon sun was dipping low, casting long, stretching shadows. Each step felt heavy, like the universe was holding its breath, giving me a moment of pause before everything changed. My heart pounded against my ribs, and my hands were clammy with nerves. I had rehearsed this conversation a hundred times in my head, but no version felt right. How do you confess something that's been eating away at you for months? How do you admit feelings you've been running from?
Before I could think about turning back, I found myself standing outside Jason's door. My hand hovered over the wood as I tried to steady my breathing. This was it. No more lies, no more masks.
I knocked.
The seconds stretched out, each one dragging longer than the last, before the door finally creaked open. There he was—Jason. His face softened the moment he saw me, his eyes widening with a mixture of surprise and something else—understanding. He didn't look shocked, though. It was almost as if he had expected this, like he had been waiting for me to show up all along.
"David?" His voice was soft, cautious, like he was testing the waters.
I swallowed hard, trying to keep my voice steady. "Can we talk?"
Jason stepped aside without a word, letting me in. His room smelled like paint and charcoal, the familiar scent of art supplies scattered in a messy, creative way that felt distinctly like him. It was the same as always, yet everything felt different. The air between us was thick with tension, heavy with the weight of what needed to be said. I sat down on the edge of his bed, and Jason sat across from me, his expression patient but alert, waiting for me to speak.
"I've been lying," I finally said, breaking the silence that had hung between us. "To you, to Ava, to everyone. But mostly, I've been lying to myself."
Jason didn't say anything at first. He just listened, his gaze locked on mine, not judging, just waiting. And that made it easier, somehow.
"I've been running," I continued, my voice shaking slightly. "Running from this... from everything. From the way I feel about you. And it's not fair. It's not fair to Ava, and it's not fair to you. I should've been honest from the beginning."
I paused, the weight of my confession pressing down on me. Jason's eyes remained steady, but there was an intensity there now, a focus that made it clear he wasn't taking this lightly.
"I have feelings for you, Jason," I said, my voice barely above a whisper. "And I don't know when they started, or how I'm supposed to handle them, but they're real. And I can't keep pretending they're not."
For a moment, the room felt like it had gone silent, like the world outside had faded away, leaving just the two of us, suspended in this fragile, vulnerable moment. I had laid everything bare, and now all I could do was wait.
Jason let out a slow breath, his expression softening. "I kind of figured," he said quietly, almost as if he didn't want to break the tension. "I felt it too. The tension. The looks. But I didn't want to push you. I didn't know if you were ready to admit it."
"I wasn't," I admitted, my throat tight. "I was scared. Scared of what it meant, scared of what people would think, scared of how it would change everything."
Jason's gaze flickered with understanding, and for the first time, I saw a glimpse of his own uncertainty. "I care about you, David. A lot. But this... this is complicated. I don't know what it means for me either."
His words stung, but I understood. This wasn't going to be easy, and I hadn't expected it to be. Jason wasn't some magic fix for all my problems. He was real, just like me, with his own fears, his own doubts.
"I get that," I said softly. "I'm not asking for anything right now. I just needed to tell you the truth. I'm tired of hiding."
Jason nodded, his gaze never leaving mine. "Thank you for being honest."
The silence that followed wasn't uncomfortable. It was filled with something else, something that felt like relief. For the first time in months, I had spoken the truth, and it was enough.
The days after our conversation passed in a blur. I hadn't expected everything to suddenly make sense or fall neatly into place, but there was a quiet sense of peace now, even in the midst of the chaos. For the first time, I wasn't weighed down by my own lies. The truth had set something in motion, something I didn't fully understand yet but knew was important.
One afternoon, as I was walking across campus, I spotted Elijah in the distance. Our eyes met, and for a second, I considered turning around, pretending I hadn't seen him. But that wasn't realistic. Avoiding him forever wasn't an option, not after everything that had happened.
Elijah approached cautiously, the usual swagger in his step absent. He stopped a few feet away from me, his hands shoved into his pockets, his eyes searching mine. "Hey, man," he said quietly, his voice hesitant. "I, uh... I'm sorry. I didn't mean for things to go down like they did."
I studied his face, taking in the apology, the weight of what we had lost between us hanging in the air. "I appreciate that," I said, my voice even. "But things are different now."
He nodded, understanding. "Yeah, I get that. But if you ever need to talk, I'm here."
I gave him a small nod, and that was it. No grand reconciliation, no dramatic apology. Just the quiet acknowledgment that some things had changed forever. Some things couldn't be undone.
That evening, as the sun set, casting long shadows across my apartment, I felt something new—a sense of calm. Life wasn't magically fixed. Things with Jason were still complicated. But I wasn't running anymore. I wasn't hiding.
I picked up my phone, my fingers hovering over the screen for a moment before I typed a simple message to Jason.
Thanks for listening.
It wasn't much, but it was enough.
As I hit send, I knew that the road ahead wouldn't be easy. There would be challenges, doubts, and moments of fear. But for the first time in my life, I was ready to face them.
No more lies. No more masks.
Just me.
YOU ARE READING
The Pages Within [BxB]
Romance"I spent so long trying to be the guy everyone else wanted me to be, that I forgot to ask who I actually was. Turns out, the hardest thing isn't letting others down-it's letting yourself in." When a journal assignment forces David Castillo- the star...