Beautiful Traitor | Reiner x OC 18+

11 [updated]

A/N: Sorry for the long wait for a new update. I was honestly too lazy to write and had no ideas. So this is a shitty chapter sorry again. It's kind of hard to come up with something with the main point is kind of over. But fear not I'm working on the other Reiner story  'Beautiful Darkness'.

———

Reiner collapses on top of me. His sweat makes him stick to my skin as he breathes heavily into my neck.

I let out a strangled grunt, patting his back. "Reiner... you're kind of heavy."

"Sorry." He mumbles before rolling off of me.

I turn onto my side to face him. Draping my leg over his and wrapping my arm around his waist. "I'm really glad my first time was with you."

Reiner's eyes soften as he leans forward to kiss my forehead. "Me too."

We lay there in comfortable silence, savoring the moment as we stay wrapped in each other's embrace. 

"I wish we could stay like this for hours. But people are probably looking for us."

Reiner groans, his fingers lazily tracing along my arm. "You're probably right."

We stay like that for a moment more before I reluctantly pull away from him. We both sit up before climbing off the bed to gather our scattered clothes.

I'm halfway through pulling on my shirt when I catch Reiner staring at me. His gaze lingering shamelessly as I slip my arms through the sleeves.

I give him a cheeky smile. "What are you staring at?"

He smirks. "Just enjoying the view before I have to shower. No point in getting dressed, right?" 

I automatically look down, my eyes landing on his dick for a moment before I quickly turn away feeling embarrassed.

Reiner lets out a small laugh as he steps forward to grab my hand. "You don't need to be embarrassed. I'm all yours Blair."

I wrap my arms around his waist, laying my head against his chest while listening to his heartbeat. "It's just... it feels kind of weird when one of us is naked, and the other is fully clothed."

"There's nothing weird about it." He replies, holding me tighter."

I pull away from him with a sigh. "I guess I have to go now. See you later?"

He nods before letting me go. Watching as I make my way to the door.

I discreetly step out into the hall, thankful for the emptiness. I only make it a few steps down the hallway before Hange appears around the corner, her eyes widening as soon as she spots me.

"Blair! Where the hell have you been? I've been looking for you!"

My mouth opens to speak but before I can reply, I hear a door open behind me.

"Blair, you forgot your— oh, Hange."

I turn to see Reiner standing with my sweater in his hand and a towel wrapped loosely around his waist.
Hange lets out a gasp. "Oh, you two—"

I quickly turn around to face her. "Please don't yell." I beg.

She nods as she bounces on the balls of her feet. "I have so many questions."

Quickly, I grab my sweater from Reiner before pulling Hange by the arm to usher her down the hall. I glance back, catching Reiner's amused expression, as he gives me a little wave before disappearing back into his room.

As we round the corner, Hange glances over her shoulder, still gawking.

She speaks quickly as she rapid fires questions at me a little too loudly. "This is amazing. I can't believe it. Were you safe? You know I didn't give that whole lecture for nothing."

"Hange please." I whisper, glancing around anxiously to see if anyone is around. "Lower your voice. I'll tell you later in private."

Her eyes glint with mischief. "Fine, but I'm holding you to that. Now tell me—was it everything you dreamed it would be?"

"Hange." I groan, I already said I would tell her later.

"Fine." She says again, sighing in defeat as we round another corner.

And of course we bump into Zeke out of all people. I try to hold back a groan as he notices us coming towards him.

"Blair." He pauses, giving me a small grin. "I've been looking for you. I heard you were... busy."

"Are you stalking me?" I mutter under my breath.

Hange nudges me, barely containing her laughter.  "Maybe we should tell him what you've been up to."

I shoot her a look, but it only fuels her amusement.

Zeke raises an eyebrow, clearly entertained. "Busy, huh? I'm curious what could keep you so occupied."

"Nothing that concerns you." I reply, crossing my arms.

"Oh, really?" He pushes off the wall, taking a step closer. "You're sure you're not hiding anything?"

"Zeke, I swear. I'll shove my foot so far up your—"

"Okay, Blair!" Hange laughs, placing a hand on my shoulder to steer me away. "Let's go before you pop a blood vessel."

She leads me through the corridors until we finally duck into a small, unused storage room. The light flickers a little as the door creaks shut.

Hange leans against the wall, vibrating with excitement. "Okay, spill! What happened?"

I scrunch my nose as I take a look around the small closet. "Is this really where you want to have a girl talk?"

Hange lets out an exaggerated sigh. "Can you just get to the good stuff?"

I roll my eyes before finally telling her. "Yes we had sex. Are you happy now?"

Hange gasps, clasping her hands together. "How was it? Was it everything you hoped for?" She peers over her glasses, eyes gleaming. "I need every single detail."

"Um, isn't that kind of... TMI?"

She waves her hand dismissively. "Oh please. Friends don't believe in TMI."

I raise an eyebrow at her. "Aren't you my boss?"

"Yeah but I'm in friend mode right now." Hange whines.

I give her a small smile before shaking my head. "I honestly don't know how to describe it. It was...amazing, honestly. To just be with someone you love in that way."

Hange's eyes widen and she bounces lightly on her feet. "I knew it! You two have so much chemistry."

"I just didn't expect everything to happen so quickly. I swear I didn't go to his room with that intention. What if it changes things between us? You know, makes things awkward?"

"Oh please." Hange scoffs. "I believe the best things happen spontaneously. If anything it should bring you guys closer."

"Yeah, you're probably right."