Lui joined you and Jeff at the house later that day.
Jeff had to go out for 'business' that evening, and decided that you needed a babysitter.
'I need to know that you're safe and protected. I can't risk you leaving the house or someone breaking it and hurting you.
I love you.'
He whispered his last sentence, so that only you could hear it. He kissed the top of your head, and leading you out of the kitchen to meet Lui in the front room.
Jeff left after talking for a few minutes with Lui, and made sure to specifically call out goodbye to you.You and Lui sat on opposite sides of the room.
You were busy reading a book you found in Jeff's bedroom. There were only a few, and you forgot to get some from your house.
'Lui'
He looked up at you from the laptop he had brought over. His blue eyes looked at you with innocence, completely different to how Jeff had looked at you that morning.
'Could we go to mine so I can grab some books to read'
His face.
'Baby you can't. You're here for protection. You could be dead by now if you weren't brought here. And don't forget your parents. Me and Jeff had to think of a believable bullshit story to tell your parents. If you suddenly turn up at the house it'll run everything; certainly at this time.'
Him calling you baby made you cringe. Only Jeff could call you that. But it was what he said about your parents that made you panic.
'What did you tell my family?'
He sighed
'We told them that you'd been kidnapped by people trying to hurt you, who we are fighting. We told them that we were trying to get you back safely, and that we would have to help you recover and get over the trauma. We told them you wouldn't be back for a while. In reality, we are protecting you so that none of that happens. We can't collect anything for you until at least a month. Your parents are under constant watch, to see if you came home unprotected. That's why Jeff never left once. He never went to sleep. He spent all night holding you.'
This all shocked you. The sound of the book hitting the floor brought you back, and you saw Lui stood in front of you with his hand on your shoulder.
'Are you okay? Do you want to go to bed?'
You agreed and he helped you upstairs. He helped you undress, his hands gently gliding over your body. His touch made you shiver; he had the same effect on you as Jeff did.
Lui's hair covered his face so that you could only see one of his eyes. He still looked as attractive as his brother did, and you couldn't help but cuddle into his chest. He wrapped his arms around you and pulled you in close. He was identical to his brother. A blonde Jeff.
For you, the next few minutes were a blur, but you were she that Lui knew exactly what he was doing.
You found him in your bed, holding you close.
'I can see why my brother saved you now. You really are beautiful.'
You cuddled into him. His sweet words and way of holding you made you trust him. Somewhere in your mind told you he wasn't Jeff, and it wasn't right; but this felt right to you, and you were sure there were feelings towards him that you couldn't ignore. Feelings that you also have for Jeff.
YOU ARE READING
Jeff x Reader
FanfictionJeff the Killer x Reader When |reader| returns home late from college drunk, they are helped by a man on the street. Waking up the next morning they find that he was Jeff, who is now living with |reader|. Eventually being moved away for protection...