Game with the best story. The winner of this category has got to be The Walking Dead.
The Walking Dead just progresses so beautifully from the beginning of one season to the next. It just blends so well that your actually anxious to figure out what happened to your favourite character in the next season. It also leaves you questioning as to if you made the right decisions along the way. That's another thing I love about, you can pick your own ending. Plus you can sometimes save or kill of a major character if your not careful.
You even end up feeling for the characters and relating to them. Usually in video games I could really care less about the other characters besides my own, but this game can bring you to tears over their deaths.