This is what he is thankful for
Dean- While he is thankful for Baby (the Impala), he is also thankful that you are so stable and steady. You are one of the few people that are constant in his life. He knows that he can count on you for anything. He knows you have his back.
Sam- He is thankful for the two people he loves most in the world; Dean and you. Sam loves that you always listen to him. Sometimes he and Dean get into fights and Dean won't listen to him, so he turns to you. He knows that you'll always listen to his side of the story and trust him.
Cas- He is thankful for you. He loves everything about you and since meeting you, you have been all he can think about. He can't imagine life without you and he would do anything for you.
Gabriel- Candy of course! But he's also thankful for your patience with him. He knows he acts childish and wants candy all the time, so he appreciates that you are willing to keep calm when he is being annoying and childish.
Bobby- His boys (Sam and Dean) and your understanding. Most people see him as a mean drunk...but you can see beyond that to the man he is. You don't know what he does for a living but you do know that he helps people and that's good enough for you. He doesn't need to share everything with you since you understand that he is not used to talking about himself.
Lucifer- Your love. He was kicked out of his home by his big brother. He needs to know someone loves him. All he really wanted was love from his family...but since they don't show love to him, he's glad that you do. It's good for him to know that he's not abandoned.
Crowley- Your sass. Sometimes he hates your sass...but even when he hates it, he loves it. You always have good comebacks and even when he tries to be upset about them, he can't help laughing at them.
Balthazar- Your originality. Some humans try to act like others but you don't care about that. You act like yourself. You don't try to be anyone else. You were born an original and you don't want to die a copy.
Adam- Your openness. You share anything that's on your mind with Adam. He doesn't have to guess what you're thinking because you'll just tell him if he asks. You also are open-minded and you don't immediately reject his ideas, which he likes because it shows you actually considered it.
Chuck- Your acceptance. Chuck has nightmares almost every night...but you don't care. You care about him just as he is. You don't think he needs to change, nor do you want him to. You take the good with the bad and help him out with the bad, so he doesn't have to face it alone.
YOU ARE READING
Supernatural Preferences
FanfictionDean, Sam, Cas, Gabriel, Lucifer, Bobby, Adam, Chuck, and possibly Balthazar. Disclaimer: I do not own any of the characters from the show