In Love With the Guy With One Eye (Human! Bill x Reader)

First Close Encounter

You make it back to the shack and Ford approaches you,

"So, (Y/N), you are aware you'll be staying here the night, yes?"

"Yeah, I am." You shrugged

"Did you have anywhere else to stay anyways?" Dipper asked

"Well I was planning on staying in my Dad's old house he has here, but it's all dusty and broken down. Not in any way of a good state to stay the night in."

"Alright," Ford walked over and patted your back, "maybe Mabel and Dipper can help you settle into their room." He winked at them causing Mabel to run over to you and grab your shirt's sleeve and dragged you upstairs.

Dipper just chuckled and grabbed your bag and headed upstairs with you two.

Mabel sat you down on her bed and she picked up the phone and dialled a number. You were confused as to what the twelve year old was doing. Then you remembered what you promised her. She started to talk on the phone,

"Hello, Candy? Hey, it's Mabel. Get Grenda because we have a makeover to do!"

You smirked and sighed with joy as Dipper cane in,

"Oh you brought my bag, thanks man!"

"No problem." He looked up to you and smiled, then you heard Bill again,

"That Pinetree won't get in the way of my plans."

You try your best to ignore him and try to continue on with a normal conversation, then there's a knock on the door. The three of you rush downstairs to see who it is and lo and behold, Candy and Grenda. Exhausted and sweaty, the walk in to again, rush upstairs and again, you being dragged by the sleeve by Mabel.

You all get back up to the bedroom and you ask,

"How did you two get here so quickly? Mabel called you 30 seconds ago."

"Well..." Candy panted, "I seen....Grenda on the street...then..I grabbed her....and sprinted with..her here."

"Wow, have you ever thought of entering in the Olympics?"

"No no...Candy loves beauty, not being sweaty from sports."

The awkward silence was broken by Grenda's shouting,

"So! Mabel, who's the new girl!!?"

"Oh, this is (Y/N)! She won a free makeover!"

"Well then," Candy put her hands together, "let's get started!"

You seen a glance of Dipper before being enclosed in a dome of these three girls applying various things to your face. You felt a bit like Dipper at this moment, kinda wishing you were somewhere else, but also loving this so much at the same time.

About fifteen minutes have past and the girls have put on lipstick, blush and eye shadow onto your face and yo u looked fantastic upon looking into the mirror.

Mabel then stood up and walked over to the closet and took out a long beautiful, grey sparkling dress that was clearly not hers. She brought it over and placed on your lap then went over to the bedside table, opened the drawer and took out a pair of beautiful hooped, tasseled earrings. That were not hers either.

She walked back over to you and pushed a bit of you hair back behind your ear that had fallen out of your neat bun. She then carefully placed them into your, mainly un-used earring holes.

"Wendy loan me her dress and these earrings were my Mom's. She wants me to wear them when I get married."

"Umm, Mabel," Dipper spoke up, "by 'loan' do you mean that you tool the dress from Wendy?"

"Does it count if I asked her while she was listening to loud music with headphones? And lyrics of that song included, "yes"?"

Dipper stared at her and shrugged, "Yeah I guess."

You put on this amazing feat of design, materialisation and clothing that reached to your feet, inside of sparkling heels. Then you let down your jet black hair with aqua blue ends that reach down to your elbows, out of the bun that it stayed in for the twenty minutes your face was being painted with makeup and you were being touched up.

For the first time Dipper had looked up from the journal to see you standing there looking magnificent then exclaimed,

"Oh, oh my gosh! (Y/N), you look astonishing, you look beautiful!"

You giggled at his loss for words, "Thank you Dipper, but I think the girls could touch you up a bit."

The girls laughed and Dipper blushed profoundly. Candy and Grenda had to go home, so they left. Then Dipper and Mabel were called downstairs by Stan for a private talk, leaving you alone in their room.

You looked at all their photos placed around the room when you get a too familiar feeling, then the door slams shut. You hear Bill's voice again, but it sounds more real this time,

"Ah, you look positively divine my dear."

You turn around to see the tall, slender man in a yellow suit with parted flaps on his thighs. The yellow brick pattern on each of them too recognisable. With cane in hand and eye patch covering his right eye only perfectly complimenting his golden hair, you were once again given shivers through your body.

You stepped back and looked him up and down quickly,
"What are you doing here?"

He stepped towards you, "To see you of course! Pinetree and Shooting Star left so I seized the opportunity to come."
He placed his hand on the wall next to you. You squeeze yourself together.

"Those girls sure can handle their make up. Not that you need it at all though."

You slip down under his arm and out behind him.

"Thanks for the compliment but I don't believe you have any good business here."

"Why the only business I have here is to take to out."
He snapped his fingers then you heard Dipper from downstairs;

"Hey (Y/N)! We're going out for the night. We all hope your coming but it's up to you!"

You turned back around to see Bill smirking. You sneered at him.

"Yeah sure, I'll be down in a minute!"
You squint your eyes at him furiously.
"I'm not letting you get away with anything and if you think I will, you're sorely mistaken."

You open the door to go downstairs to join the rest of them. Bill could sense the anger in you and jokingly said;

"Sweetie's got some fury in her talk and fire in her eyes."

You immediately slam the door shut and then walk downstairs. Bill disappeared in a puff of smoke. You decided it was best not to tell the rest of them Bill that was there just yet.

You walk downstairs to see Wendy, Dipper, Mabel and Stan neat and tidy in decent clothing ready to go out. Wendy sees you and says, "Guys," and taps the others. She doesn't seem bothered at all that you're wearing her dress.

She whispers to Dipper; "Umm, Dipper. Who's she?"

"Oh right!" Dipper said, "You two haven't really met yet. (Y/N), this is Wendy, one if the Shack's employees. And Wendy, this is (Y/N), she arrived in gravity falls today and I guess we all clicked as friends." He smiled gleefully with Mabel hoping Wendy didn't notice her dress on you.

"Oh wow (Y/N), you look beautiful!"

"Thank you Wendy." You say in a curtsy. "So where are we going?"

"Oh! We're going out to this great fair! It's just down the road and it should be a ton of fun."

"Okay then, if everyone's ready...." Mabel cuts you off;

"LET'S GO!!"