In Love With the Guy With One Eye (Human! Bill x Reader)

A Long Night Ahead

You just get in the door and you feel like falling because of how tired you are. The twins and Wendy help hold you up as you walk in. You're thinking if now would be the time to tell them about Bill and ask Dipper if he's told the others about the encounter with him outside the circus yet.

"Well, see you guys tomorrow. That was really fun." Wendy waved as she walked out the door.

"Bye Wendy." You all say together.

"Um, Dipper?" You tugged at his shirt.

"Yes (Y/N)?"

"I need to talk to you. Privately." You whispered.

"Okay?"

The two of you went upstairs to the twins' room to talk while Mabel was busy downstairs. You sat on Mabel's bed and he sat on his own.

"Is there something wrong?" He asked with great concern.

"Well, it's about Bill. And what happened outside the tent, I want to explain it more." You carefully hide your palm.

"Oh yea, yea. You can talk to me, or even Ford, anytime you feel is necessary." He smiled.

"Well, I just wanted to ask, what where your first thoughts when you seen Bill there? And human.."

"I didn't really acknowledge the "human-ness", sure I noticed he wasn't a small floating triangle but that wasn't my main concern. All I could think if was, What's Bill doing here? and if he was harming you."

"That's very thoughtful of you Dipper but the worst part of it is, *sigh*, that's not the first time I've spoken to him, face-to-face."

"Wait, WHAT?! (Y/N), even if he did just talk to you there, outside the tent would be an issue. But more than once? THAT'S A BIG ISSUE."

"I know, I could kinda tell."

"How many times have you two actually spoken?"

"Two or three. More than once."
Not counting the next one tomorrow

"Alright, but is he hurting you? Or showing any signs of wanting to hurt you?"

"No, not at all."
But he seems to be in love with me

"Okay, we'll sleep this off tonight and maybe we can talk to Ford about it in the morning."

Dipper got up to start going downstairs. You stopped him,
"Dipper, did you tell anyone about what you saw outside the tent?"

"No. Why?"

"Just wondering."

He smiled and started to walk towards the door. He opened it half way and stuck his head out,

"Seems like Ford ordered some pizza for us all. Care to join us?" He looked back at you.

"Sure. Just give me a minute." He smiled and closed the door.

You expected Bill to pop up next to you, but no. He must be keeping something special for tomorrow morning. You gathered yourself and got up to go downstairs. You closed the door behind you and the smell of freshly baked pizza cheers you up a bit. Mabel was sitting at the table in the kitchen. You noticed Dipper talking Ford behind the stairs and you stopped, then listened closely to what they were saying;

"Ford, I'm really worried about (Y/N). She just told me that she talked with Bill face-to-face more than once, and even she could tell that was a serious issue herself."

"Okay, okay....that is serious. We'll talk to her when she comes down."

You thought it would be best to just leave it a few minutes so it didn't seem like you were eavesdropping and came down straight after. So you went back upstairs and got changed into something more comfortable. A woman's favourite black leggings and a T-shirt.