Peter pan/ Robbie Kay imagines

Truth or dear

"Hey guys!" I shouted through the whole camp when running towards the bonfire spot. All Lost Boys looked up and towards me from whatever they were just doing. "Do you wanna play a game?" I asked everyone smirking. They all smirked back, stood up and started to form a circle around me. "Great." I said clapping my hands together, then sitting down on the ground. Everyone did the same. "So what's the game now?" Nathan, one of the older ones asked impatiently. "So me and my friends, back in Storybrooke used to play this funny game called 'Truth or Dare'. First thing we need is some kind of bottle." I stood up to get my old dusty water bottle from my hunting bag and threw it into the centre of the circle. "And what're we gonna do with it?" Nathan continued. "Put it in your ass." I heard Felix whisper. Everyone laughed. "No actually we're gonna put it in the middle of this circle and spin it around until the bottleneck points at someone, who then has to either honestly answer a question or do a task the person who spun the bottle chooses. Understood?" I asked looking around into confused faces. "Not? Well then we gotta do learning by doing. I'll start." I said smirking. I tried to give the bottle as much swing as I could and it stopped right in front of Felix's lap. "Truth or Dare Felix?" I asked excited. "So if I pick Truth now I just gotta answer one little question?" He asked confused. "Yep." I said leaning backwards, putting all of my weight on my hands. "Then I'll pick Truth." He said snorting. "Oh don't celebrate just yet, Felix." I said sneeringly. "Who was your first love?" I asked him raising my eyebrow at him smirking. Suddenly his smile fell from his face and he turned red and started blushing. "Do I really have to answer this?" He said evasively. "Yes you do." I said reproachfully. "It was... I... I can't say this, it's too embarrassing." He said blushing even more. Suddenly I heard leaves cracking. At first I thought it was some kind of danger but then Peter came to my mind, who I haven't seen around all day. And then finally a handsome guy with soft brown hair, green eyes, brown hunting clothes, bow and arrow in his hands appeared from out of the woods. "Peter! Come on join us! Felix was just about to tell us a very interesting story." Felix, who thought I'd forget all about his dirty mystery, due to Peter's appearing started to blush again and punched me on the arm. "I was not." He said defiantly. "Yeah you were." I said punching him back. Peter quickly put away his hunting equipment and sat down next to me. "A secret, huh? What would that be?" He smirked raising an eyebrow at me. I turned to look at him. "He just wanted to tell us who his first real love was." Peter smiled mockingly. "That's very nice of you Felix."And after another five minutes of discussion Felix finally gave in to us. "It was Wendy." He quickly said rolling his eyes at us. My jaw dropped when I realized what Felix had just said. "Our Wendy?" I asked in disbelief. "Can't be." One of the other boys added. "Can we talk about something and someone else now?" Felix asked playfully annoyed. "Fine, fine." I said just about to grab the bottle. "And what is all this good for? Why did Felix just tell everyone the truth about his first love." "Because that's what the rules are like." I said turning my head putting it onto my knees, looking straight into Peter's eyes. Every time I looked at him his eyes captured me like an actual lock. "We're playing a game?" He asked confused but amused. "Yeah we are." I chuckled. "Count me in whatever game this is." He said smirking, typical of Peter. He loved games and he was hella good at playing them. "You'll quickly learn it." I said ruffling through Peter's hair. We spun the bottle several times more, and several more secrets came to light. Nathan for example had revealed his secret of being an actually good cook, Clint has never been kissed before and one of the boys Andrew, had chosen Dare and had to kiss one of the other boys on the cheek. Most of the Dare ideas came from Peter, and because they were so mean and funny most of the boys just adopted them. "Great so now it's my turn." Peter simply said, grabbing the bottle. "That's not fair!" I said punching him on the arm. "I decide what's fair and what's not." He said pushing my face to the side. The bottleneck again showed to Felix, who this time took dare, which was not really a better choice than truth anyway. "Okay so you and Nathan have to take off all your clothes and run around naked for at least 3 minutes in camp." Peter said smirking. "WHAAT?!" They both screamed out in disbelief. "Either do it freely or I'll make you do it." Peter said smirking devilishly. "Magic's against the rules!" I said pushing his raised hand down again. "Fineee." Peter groaned. "But they still have to do it right?" He asked me smirking. I nodded. "Oh just wait for the moment, when it's your turn! I'll pay everything back to you. I swear." Felix said deadpan.
"You ready?" Peter shouted through the whole camp. Felix and Nathan were both standing behind a tree. "You know what Felix? I hate you for letting me go down WITH you!" Nathan said deadpan. "Go." Peter shouted and let out a satisfied sigh. "You're really enjoying this, aren't you?" I said smirking. "Of course I am." He said chuckling. The next thing he did was making boys do a model runway walk through camp, making them pour an ice cold bucket of water over their head, wrapping themselves up in toilet paper and he even made on boy take a piggy back ride on someone else's back for at least five minutes. "Truth or Dare, y/n?" I thought about it for a second. I didn't want to answer the 'who are you in love with' questions and all this other personal stuff so I decided against Truth. "I take Dare, eventhough the tasks are amazingly mean and crazy here." I said giving Peter a significant look. "Sit down on the lap of the person to your right for the rest of the game." Julian said smirking. "What?" I asked in disbelief looking to the right were Peter was sitting. He smirked at me but I couldn't laugh. I was terrified, I couldn't sit down on Peter's lap, I couldn't feel all this near to him because actually I was madly in love with this guy and the desire to kiss him was terrifyingly high. I was afraid of making a complete fool of myself, because when people were in love with someone they always behaved strange towards that special person. Also Peter didn't seem to have any great interest in me, which made everything even worse. Sure we were very close and sometimes he hugged me or took my hand but nothing more developed and so I one day came to the conclusion that maybe he didn't want something to develop between us. "On Peter's lap?" I asked again, standing up slowly, but as soon as I was on my feet, Peter grabbed my waist and pulled me down on him. "Like this, love." He whispered into my ear, which sent shivers through my whole body. He let his hands rest on my belly and kept hugging me from behind which changed my impression of Peter's seeming disinterest a little, but didn't whip it out completely. I smiled at everyone while internally I was screaming and jumping and crying because I was so happy to feel his warmth and his closeness. After a while it was Peter's turn again and he chose me. "So y/n truth or dare this time?" He asked smirking. I wouldn't choose dare because I was afraid that I would have to stand up or go away from him, and I didn't want to so I simply picked truth. "So who was your first love then?" He asked with an attentive look in his eyes. "Weeelll..." I had to think about it a little. When did I feel love for the first time? Ages ago. In Kindergarten maybe? Or elementary school. "I think it was in Kindergarten when this guy, Thomas always shared his food with me and it made me so happy that one day I gave him a cute little kiss on the cheek for having done so all this time and I guess that was my 'first love' somehow." I turned my head to look at Peter who had a nervous look in his eyes. "So you actually kissed this guy... Like.. What was his name again? Thomas? Did you have any nicknames for each other? For how long has he been giving your food and what was his last name again?" Peter bettered me with loads of questions... "Peter..." He wouldn't stop talking. "Peter... Peter!" I said loudly and he fell silent. "What's?" He asked quietly, looking me straight in the eyes. "This guy didn't mean a thing to me, it was a Kindergarten 'relationship' and you know what? Not even that, he only shared food with me, no reason to hunt him down." I said ironically. Peter's sudden jealousy was too cute. "I've spent so many beautiful hours on this island, I already forgot completely about my old life. What counts is the present, and I found a guy here, I really, really like." "What? Who is it? Let me guess it's Nathan... Felix? Maybe Julian? Just give me a hint, just a little tip..." Peter went on talking for at least two other minutes before I silenced him again. "Peter!" I hesitated for a second and then I just said it out loud. "It's you." I admitted softly. "You're the guy I like." I added blushing, while everyone around us cheered and yelled. "I'm... The guy... You like?" He said nervously going through his hair, looking to the ground blushing. "Yes it's you. All this time it's been you." I said sitting down on his lap properly so I could face him. He then cupped my face in both of his hands and gave me a soft peck on the lips. "I have to admit that I really really like you too."