Peter pan/ Robbie Kay imagines

You Lied

Peter and I had been together for a while now (I honestly can't tell you how long, I mean, there's no time on Neverland). Ever since that ditz Wendy came to Neverland, claiming to be lost might I add, Peter's been distant. We all knew Wendy wasn't lost. Only desperate.

All of the lost boys have agreed that she was way too clingy, but of course, Peter disagreed and kept her with us. Wendy wasn't rude or anything like that. She was simply... sweet and unaware. Unaware of Peter and I's relationship. I've hinted at it but she never picked up what I put down.

"Hey, Peter." I smiled at him as he walked up to me. "Hello, darling." He sat next to me. "How was hunting?" I asked. He simply sighed. "We didn't get much. Only small things. Puny, might I say." Peter rested his forearms on his knees and picked up his flute. "Well, that's too bad." I frowned a bit, glancing at the lost boys. "Yeah." He sighed. I watched his face, looking for any expression, when he paled just a bit. "Peter, are you alright?" I asked. He only shook his head. "Someone's on the island, I have to go and see who." He stood. I nodded, though he was facing away, and watched him walk off.

I looked away when he had passed enough branches and bushes that made it hard to see. However, as I looked away, I saw Wendy following after Peter. "What is she doing?" I asked myself, standing from where I was sitting. I followed Wendy quietly as she followed Peter. "Finally, I thought we'd never escape her." I heard. Wendy had stopped walking. "I don't know about all of this. I mean, she'll find out soon enough." "I think we should tell her." "Tell her what? That her boyfriend had been cheating on her with the new arrival." "Peter, you need to know your own feelings. Can you imagine a life without her?" "Well, I don't know, I mean, maybe." "And how about me." "That's harder." "So, you have feelings for me. That proves that we need to tell her."

"No, don't bother." I stepped out from where I was and stepped towards them. "Y/N-" "No, Peter. You're cheating on me. Do you honestly think there's an excuse for that?" I asked, starting to pace slightly. "Look, Y/N, I didn't-" "Wendy, would you please. Stop. Talking." I glared at her. "Y'know what?" I laughed dryly. "You two can continue here and I'll just go back to camp. Let's just act like this never happened. 'Kay?" I held a fake smile and then turned, walking briskly back down the path I came. "Wow. Who would've thought?" I asked myself, laughing at my stupidity. "Who would've thought what?" I jumped. "Oh my- Felix!" I hit the blonde boy's arm. "Well, go on, tell me." He pushed. I rolled my eyes and sighed. "Peter and Wendy." I stated. "Wait, what?" Felix asked. "Together. Secret meetings. No Y/N." I looked down. Felix set an arm over my shoulders awkwardly.

"But, I have a plan." I said, glancing up at the tall blonde. He smirked. "Am I part of it?" He asked. I nodded and smirked back. "You are the plan." I told him.

"Alright, go." I whispered, spotting Peter walking towards the ring of dancing lost boys. He looked around. "So, Felix..." I trailed off, leaning towards him and fluttering my eyelashes. "Are you the best archer?" I giggled a bit. God I hope that giggle sounded normal. "One of the best." Felix put on a fake smug smirk. I giggled again. "How about you teach me sometime?" I smiled sweetly, setting my hand on his bicep. "I could teach you now." He suggested, picking his bow up from beside him. I was bout to reply when someone did for me. "I don't think that's a wise idea."

I turned to see Peter glaring at the both of us. "Pan." Felix greeted. Peter sneered at him. "Yeah yeah, get lost." I almost laughed. Pun intended, I thought. Felix stood and walked away slowly. "Flirting with my best lost boy? Really?" Peter asked. "Cheating with the new arrival? Really?" I mocked, glaring at him. "Look, Y/N, I thought I liked her. I thought that she was the one and our relationship-" "Didn't matter?" I cut him off.

"No, I thought that our relationship wasn't right- no that sounds bad. I mean..." He sighed, not continuing. "I didn't really think things were going well between us. I have never been around girls for too long, you know that. I don't really know what to expect or what to actually do." He had sat down next to me by then, staring down at his lap and moving his hands every few words to gesture distress. "Peter..." I sighed. "No, no, it's fine. I understand if you'd rather be with Felix, or...or even go home." Peter sighed. "Peter. It was all a plan." I told him. He looked at me confused.

"What do you mean?" He asked. I smiled a bit. "Thought I'd get back at you for cheating." I said. He set a hand on his chest and let out a relieved breath. "So, you and Felix aren't...?" He trailed off. I shook my head, my smile widening. "Never." I said. "Well, on that note, Y/N," He paused an turned to me, taking my hand in his. "Would you forgive me?" He asked. "For?" I asked, shocking him. He composed himself though. "For cheating on you with Wendy." He stated, looking down a bit. "And?" I asked. "And hurting your feelings." He said. "And?" I asked once more. He looked up, confused. "And for... telling Felix to get lost?" He asked me. I smiled and instead of him kissing my hand, I kissed his. "You're forgiven." I whispered, looking him in the eyes.

He sighed. "Thank god. Now tell me, what do girls like?" He sat up straight and leaned towards me, waiting for an answer. I laughed. "You'll find out soon Peter. Go say sorry to your lost boy." I hit his shoulder lightly. "Now." I commanded. He pouted a bit but stood anyways, going to say sorry. "God, these boys are gonna kill me."