Pretty Little Liar Preferences

You two get a pet

Jason: A cat. Jason took the job of naming him. He chose Tom, it was simple and fit Tom's personality.

Toby: A dog. You named the long haired golden retriever Thor. No reason other than he seemed to have a thunderous bark.

Mike: You already had a horse named Jamison. Mike had became fond of Jamison and claimed him as both of you two's horse.

Caleb: You found a cute little black kitten wondering the streets. You took him back to the apartment. You named him Loki. Caleb was surprised when he came to find you and Loki playing with some yarn on the living room floor. He really hated when Toby and his GF brought over their dog Thor.

Ezra: A hamster. Neither of you were a big animals. No you got a hamster and named her Stella. She was cute and smart. You both loved Stella very much.