Audrey was accused of being the killer, and you believe it.
________________________________________________________
"Why you Audrey? I trusted you!" You screamed tears running down your face.
"It's not me Y/N! Trust me God damn it!" She yelled back throwing her arms around.
"I can't. Everything leads back to you. You brought Piper to Lakewood and look how that turned out!"
"I didn't know it was her Y/N! I was with Piper when Rachel died!" Audrey yelled coming closer to you.
"Get away from me Audrey." you cried out backing away from Audrey, not trusting her anymore.
"Please. Baby." Audrey pleaded tears going down her cheeks.
"I don't want to be with you. If you are the killer, turn yourself in. Where is the mask?" You pleaded.
"I don't have the mask! I'm not the killer!" She screamed.
You scoffed and grabbed your bag walking out of Audrey's house getting into your car. You drove to Noahs house still crying when you walked up to his bedroom door, knocking on it.
"Noah it's me." You said walking into the room glancing at the murder board, seeing Audrey's picture with 'prime suspect' written on the top.
"Hey Y/N, I guess someone told you about Audrey then."
"I just can't believe it. She kept telling me that she isn't the killer. What if she is being staged?" You rambled sitting down on Noahs bed.
"I saw something on her phone."
"What?"
"I stole her phone and saw a gif of her with Jakes body." Noah mumbled looking down.
"Oh my god. It's real then? She's the killer?" You whispered tears in your eyes.
"I guess, I can't believe it." Noah said.
"Don't turn her in. Noah do not tell anyone." You said seriously walking up to Noah and putting your hands in front of him. You started pacing the room pulling your hair with stress.
"I love her Noah! And she killed all of our friends!" You yelled starting to sob dropping to the floor covering your mouth with your hand.
"I know, I know. What should we tell everyone?" Noah asked.
"N-no! We are not telling anyone until she confesses to it!" You said grabbing a tissue and wiping your face.
Your phone was blowing up with texts and calls from Audrey, you reading the texts.
Baby.
Please believe me it's not me
Why would you even think that's me Y/N!??!??!
Please answer me I need to know you're okay
Y/N, please.
No one is answering their phones, baby please.
Y/N I need to know if you're okay.
What if your not okay?!
You sigh looking down at your phone. You want to text her back but it's safer not to.
"She seems worried Noah. What if she actually cares?" You ask sitting your phone down on the table.
"I don't know. We have school tomorrow and we'll have to see her. My mom will be home soon." Noah said while you were getting ready to leave.
That night you laid in bed staring at your ceiling thinking about everything that happened.
You walked to your locker opening it and grabbing all the books you need when you heard someone running up behind you.
"Y/N!" You heard Audrey yell. She walked up next you while you slammed your locker closed.
"No, Audrey." You sighed walking back.
"Y/N wait." She grabbed your wrist and you pulled away.
"Do not touch me." You growled at her.
"Why are you so angry at me?"
"I trusted you! And you broke my heart!" The two of you have now made a crowd of students watching you fight.
"You broke my heart and won't stop, just get away from me!" You screamed shoving her into a locker getting a gasp out of her and Emma, you started running to the front door of the school.
