Sophomore Year [glee fanfic, Finn Hudson]

The Rhodes Not Taken

Here we were again singing the same old Journey song, Mr Shue was teaching Matt, Puck and Mike the routine as Quinn learned the lead. I still can't wrap my head around the fact that she is pregnant.
Finn; A singer in a smoky room
Quinn; Asmell of wine and cheap perfume
Finn and Quinn; For a smile they can share the night
                                     It goes on and on and on and on
Suddenly Quinn stopped and covered her mouth, she quickly made a b lime for the bathroom.
"Quinn, you okay?" Mr Shue called after her but she was already gone.
"I think she just had a bad breakfast burrito." Finn defended and I rolled my eyes. I can't stand seeing him. I know we aren't together I mean I have Matt and he obviously has Quinn but it's the fact that he didn't tell me what was going on. This secret is too much of a burden on me but I can't tell it.
"Can we please talk about the giant elephant in the room?" Kurt asked
"Your sexuality?" Santana insulted Kurt however he just shrugged it off and continued with what he was saying.
"Rachel. We can't do it without her. - "
"That's not true. We may have to layer Lysney or Mercedes over Quinn's solo but we'll be fine." Mr Shue said, I'm pretty sure Quinn and I were meant be sharing all of Rachel's solos?
"Maybe for the invitationals, but not for the sectionals. Certainly not the regionals." Artie said. One week they're complaining about Rachel and the next they want her back, there's no winning with these people.
"The wheelchair kid's right. Rachel makes me wanna light myself on fire, but she can sing." Puck just learn his name please.
"Rachel left, guys. She's gone. Now, if we're gonna make this thing work, we can't look back. Take five, guys. " Mr Shue sighed and walked over to the piano followed by Finn. I know I shouldn't but I couldn't help but eavesdrop. Matt walks over to me and starts talking but I don't listen.
"Um, Mr. Schue? I don't wanna tell you how to do your job but with all the dancing around that Quinn's doing, I'm kinda worried about the baby. "
"Yeah. Yeah, I get it. Um How about I give Tina a few of her verses? Okay? "
"Okay. "
"You think you might wanna tell your mom what's going on? "
I never even thought about how Carol would take it.
" I think I'd rather handle it myself right now. My mom's got enough to worry about."
Oh come on Finn, you idiot, just ask someone for help. Anyone. Just talk to me again. Please.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I sighed as I walked to glee club, Finn was still ignoring me and was showing Quinn more attention that usual. I turned round the corner and bumped into someone, I dropped my books and went straight down to get them. Unfortunately the person I bumped into wanted to help. I looked up to see who it was and just my luck it was the boy who had been ignoring me. Speak of the devil...
"Sorry Lysney" Finn said as he passed me my notebook, I just grabbed it and started walking again.
"Hey wait up!" He called as he ran after me. I picked up my pace and started walking faster. Unfortunately Finn caught up. "Hey hey hey".
"What's with the cold shoulder?" He asked me, and I scoffed.
"I'm giving you the cold shoulder?" I asked back, he went to answer and I put my hand up. "Rhetorical question" I added and he shut his mouth. "You've done nothing but ignore me since, well you know. And I'm hurt. Not because of the situation you guys are in but because you were having sex with her and proceeded to string me along"
"Oh you're one to talk Collins" he said and I just looked up at him disgusted. "You're forgetting that you also have a boyfriend, and I can just turn this all round on you. You're doing the same mindless flirting with me that I am doing to you. We're no different."
We stood outside the choir room door.
"Oh we are so different" I said before opening the door. "I didn't cheat on my pregnant girlfriend" I said quietly before walking into the class room.
"Right okay looks like we've got everyone here now" Mr Shue said as Finn and I took our seats at opposite ends of the room. There was a short blonde and tan woman standing right next to him.
"Guys, I'd like to introduce you to someone very special. This is April Rhodes. She's our newest member."
"Wait, so old people can join Glee Club now?" Finn asked, what an idiot.
"Old, huh? You guys look like the world's worst Benetton ad." The short blonde woman who I'm assuming is April said.
"Mr. Schuester, this seems like a terrible idea." Artie said.
"April is a great singer. And she never graduated."
"We appreciate what you're trying to do, but she's no Rachel" Kurt stated.
"Who's Rachel?" April asked.
"Sh-Sh-She's kind of our star." Tina answered.
"Your star, eh? Well, where is she?"
"She left. To be the lead in Cabaret" I said.
"Hey, Tinkles, gimme "Maybe This Time" in B-flat. And don't let me catch you snoozin'" April ordered Brad.
[Cue "Maybe This Time]
April; Maybe this time,
I'll be lucky
Maybe this time
He'll stay
Maybe this time
For the first time
Love won't hurry away
He will hold me fast
I'll be home at last
Not a loser anymore
Like the last time
And the time before
Everybody loves a winner
So nobody loved me
Lady peaceful, Lady happy
That's what I want to be
All of the odds are
They're in my favor
Something's bound to begin
It's gotta happen
Happen sometime
Maybe this time I'll win
Cuz
Everybody they love a winner
So nobody loved me
Lady peaceful, Lady happy
That's what I want to be
All of the odds are
They're in my favor
Something's bound to begin
It's gotta happen
Happen sometime
Maybe this time I'll win
Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh!!!