Fillie: Not Just Friends

3/ Omg! Finn can sInG!

Watch the video to see what Finn sings later in the game. Omg I'm freaking out it's so GOOOD! His voice cracks give me life.

Millie's POV

I waited for Finn to respond. It took him a while, what's the big deal? It's just truth or dare.

"Uh, dare," Finn says.

"Alright then, let me think," I say.

I feel a devilish grin spread across my face. Finn sees it, his eyes widen in fear, but he's still smiling.

"Oh no!" Noah exclaims, "I know that look. The look of pure evil MILSTER!"

The group breaks out into laughter. When it dies down, it's time for Finn to take his dare.

"Finn, I dare you to...." I add a huge pause for suspense, "sing. Any song, but it has to be serious, you have to try your best."

Finn looked like someone just told him his grandma had just passed away. I literally heard him gulp.

"Oh, this is going to be GOOD," Gaten says excitedly.

I'm quite excited myself, I wonder what song he'll sing. I've only heard him sing one other time, for a very short time. I want to hear it full out this time. His cheeks are turning slightly pink.

"Okay, uh, l-let me think of a song."

He must of sat there and thought about what song to sing for three minutes. The suspense was KILLING me!

"Okay, " he says, "got it."

Noah whispers quite loudly, "You got this, Finny." This doesn't seem to help Finn at all.

He starts, "With your feet in the air and your head on the ground/ try this trick and spin it, yeah/ your head will collapse/ but there's nothing in it/ and you'll ask yourself/ where is my mind/ wheeere is my minnd/ whheeere is my mind/ 🎶 " This song is Where is my Mind by the Pixies- in the video up top. (Finn and his band did a cover!)

My jaw dropped and my mouth hung open. It was actually really good, so good that I got chills, and a warm, fuzzy feeling spread through my whole body. How is that possible? To feel warm and tingling, yet have chills at the same time? I guess the warmth was more inside of me, but what did it mean?

"And you told us you couldn't sing!" I practically yell at him, I shove my index finder in his chest.

Noah says enthusiastically, "Wow Finn, that was good!"

Gaten starts to clap, and we all join along. Finn's cheeks turn a brilliant shade of pink.

"Haha, alright... Gaten! Truth or dare?" Finn says, breaking up the applause.

"Truth," Gaten responds cooly.

Finn thinks for a minute.

"Okay. Gaten, do you have a crush on someone in set?" He asks.

"Nope," Gaten says with ease, he's not lying.

"Caleb! Truth or dareeeee?" Gaten asks with a funny accent. This makes me laugh a bit.

"Dare."

"I dare you to tell me your crush! It doesn't have to be the whole group." Dustin winks.

Caleb whispers in Gaten's ear very quietly. Finn leans in to try and hear, but the look on his face tells me that I didn't hear it.

Gaten's eyes widen, and he grins.

I can barley make out Caleb saying don't tell anyone.

"NOAHHHHHHH!" Caleb says, "truth or dare."

Classic. Dramatic.

"Dare," Noah says, in an extremely bizarre accent I can only guess is supposed to be Scottish? But it's not a very good impression.

I laugh, so does Finn and Gaten. Caleb seems to be almost there, but trying to hold it in.

"Noah, I dare you to..." Caleb trails off, and he looks at me. Why is he looking at me for? He smirks, but then resumes his question, "go outside a scream a quote from our show, as loud as you can."

"Challenge accepted," Noah states.

This is gonna be GOOD. We follow Caleb to the back door, and Noah steps outside. I prepare my phone so I can take a video.

I press record.

Noah takes a deep breath, and screams, "MORNINGS ARE FOR COFFEE AND CONTEMPLATION!"

We all laugh, I stop recording.

"That was brilliant," I say.

"One of my personal favorites," Noah replies.

"We should stay and play the game out here," Gaten suggests.

"Okay," Finn says.

"Sounds good," Caleb adds on. I nod my head. We sit in a circle on the grass. The sun was setting, shining a beautiful, rich orange color, that fades out into pink, and then to blue in the sky.

I could tell, this game was going to get really fun. This night was going to be great.

A/N: Do the truths and dares that the gang do get more personal? Things will get interesting in the next chapter, stay tuned. I hope you enjoyed! Prepare for the Fillie Feels! 💗