Fillie: Not Just Friends

13/ OH

"Never have I ever...had a crush on someone with brown eyes," Gaten says.

"That's vague, but oddly specific at the same time," Millie giggles, everyone puts one of their five fingers down.

Finn and Millie make eye contact and blush.

"I've always thought you have to prettiest brown eyes I've ever seen," Finn whispered in her ear. Shivers went down Millie's spine and she blushes profusely.

"There's just something about your dark brown eyes that melted me, right then and there when I first looked at you, not that I had a crush on you then, but your eyes always entranced me," Millie whispered back, smirking at how red Finn's cheeks got.

"Alright, y'all can stop reciting love poems to each other over there," Caleb says jokingly.

"Never have I ever..." Caleb smirks and looks at Millie, "had a fake bloody nose."

"Oh my god! Really Caleb?" She laughs, putting down a finger, Finn puts one down as well.

"When did you have a fake bloody nose Finn?" Noah asks curiously.

"It was for small project a few years back."

Noah nods, "Cool."

Sadie perks up, "Never have I ever... rode a bicycle into a bush."

The boys all look at each other and laugh, each putting a finger down, remembering the time they have all rode their bikes into a bush consecutively while shooting Stranger Things.

Gaten snorts, "The Duffers were so mad because we kept wasting filming time, because we kept crashing!"

Now it's Millie's turn, "Never have I ever eaten a Twinkie."

All the boys stare at her "Really?"

"I grew up in England..."

"Oh yeah..." they say all together, making Millie laugh.

Everyone except for Millie puts a finger down. It was Finn's turn, he thought hard for a moment, and the an idea popped into his head. A devilish grin spread across his freckled cheeks.

"Never have I ever had a crush on someone with red hair."

Caleb's eyes widen, he gulps, quickly putting down a finger, hoping Sadie, who was typing away on her phone, wouldn't notice.

But she does, and soon her cheeks flush a deep pink, she looks down at her lap.

Noah smiles mischievously, knowing how to kill five birds with one stone.

"Never have I ever been in a musical."

Yells of protest and of annoyance come from everyone, "Really Noah?" Sadie asks loudly.

"Wow dude, woooow," Caleb adds.

"It's just a game guys!" Millie lightens the mood, as per usual.

Finn smiles at her.

"Hey, I'm happy to have been on broadway," Gaten says cheekily.

"Same here," Caleb raises his Sprite can, clinking it with Gaten's Dr. Pepper.

It's later on in the game, Caleb, Finn, and Millie are out. The game was getting more and more intense, and more personal.

Noah laughed, thinking he could easily get Sadie out, he smirked, "Never have I ever had a crush on a boy."

Sadie puts her finger down laughing, now out of the game. Gaten's heart beat sky rocketed, should he do it and be truthful to his friends? Gaten nods slightly to himself, these are his best friends, they should know.