I don't blame you (Alexria fan fiction)

I'm not who you think I am

Alex's POV

I walk next to Aria as we approach my lair. "Isn't this the house Toby built for you?" Aria asks. She doesn't know that I'm not Spencer, she mustn't noticed when I spoke to her. I stay silent and guide her into the house.

"You moved your stuff in here already?" She questions. I move her to the back of the house and down to the underground cells. I was originally behind Aria until I see the empty cells and walk past her.

"Spence, what is this?" Aria asks. I'm done lying to her. I need her help and she needs to trust me for that. "Aria I'm sorry." I say. I'm so tired of this. "What is up with the accent, Spence wha-" I put my lips on hers and listen to the silence. It's bittersweet actually, I'm upset that my prisoners are gone, but the peaceful silence makes for the perfect moment. I hope it never ends.

Aria's POV

I felt paralyzed, Spencer's lips on mine stopped me from moving. I want to move but this just feels so right. I didn't know Spencer liked me that way, but she could have Toby. I have Ezra, I love him, at least I think I do. She breaks the kiss and stares sadly in my eyes. "I'm not Spencer." She says in the same accent as before. I start to get scared. "Who are you?" I ask. "Alex, Alex Drake."

Spencer's POV

Ezra and I run down the long hallway taking twist and turns until we find a door. Ezra grabs the wheel on the door and turns it to the left, loosening it. We run to the outside world and I call for help. "Hello?""Stop." Ezra says. He looks around and realizes something. "We're still underground."

Alex's POV

     I lead Aria outside when I see that the doors open. I looked at the Aria who shakes her head, telling me that she didn't leave the door open. I grab an axe off the wall for protection as we slowly creep outside. We see Spencer and Ezra standing there staring back at us. I look to Aria, who is in pure shock.

Just then, Toby and Spencer's friends show up. "Stop right there!" He yells. Ezra steps to the side and I stand in front of Aria to protect her. "Which one is Spencer?" I hear Alison ask Emily. I walk away from aria and stand next to Spencer, who pleads for her life as Toby points his gun towards the both of us. Toby suddenly walks over to me, I think he's going to choose me, though I don't know if I want him to.

     I give him a happy smile as if I'm Spencer, until he goes behind me and grabs my arms, holding them behind my back. "What's your favorite poem from the book you gave me?" He asks. I stare blankly as I try to remember. There were no words in the book. Uh oh. I look to see Spencer telling him the poem in French with loving eyes. She loves him, she can take him. A police officer comes over to me and grabs my arms, placing them in handcuffs. He starts to move me forward until someone jumps in front of us. "Wait!" The person says. "Aria what are you doing?" I ask. She ignores me and suddenly kisses me, right in front of Ezra. I melt into the kiss, and when we pull away I see the shocked faces. "Wait , what just happened?" Hanna asks.  

    Ezra approaches us and looks to Aria for an explanation. "She told me her story, I understand why she did all this, if you all listen she will tell you. Alex isn't a bad person. " "Alex?" Emily asks. "Alex Drake, my twin sister, she's A.D." Spencer says. Soon, the looks of disgust surround me. "Yeah she's A.D. but she had a good reason." Aria defends. "Well, what is that the reason because if that reason is good enough to prove why we've been tortured, I'd love to hear it." Hanna says.

   Spencer and Aria both told the others my story, some seemed convinced, though Hanna and the officer did not. I just hope they all believe it.