Creepypasta x reader lemon/fluff

Ticci toby x reader

(Warning contains sexual content and language )

"*tic* are you *tic* almost home y/n *tic*" "yes Toby" you answered talking to your boyfriend over the phone. He had offered to come pic you up but you said no because you didn't want him to be spotted. Of course he could just kill them but you weren't in the mood for that. You continued on you walk home and felt a Tap on your shoulder "Toby I told you not to..." you stopped talking looking up to see a random stranger. You were about to reach for your phone to call Toby but the man took it from you.  "Now now" he said " we don't need to call that little Toby of yours I'm sure I'm much better looking ." He said taking a step closer until he backed you into a wall.
"I beg to differ" you said
"Oh really?" He answered
"Yep"
"Oh I can make you beg." The man said before beginning to unzip his pants. 'Toby plz hurry' you thought to yourself. You than began to see the mans dick come out of his pants you tried to look away but he forced you to keep looking. He was about to say 'get on your hands and knees' until his dick was cut off at first it scared you as blood went everywhere and he began screaming but then you realized who had done it and you looked up into the eyes of none other than Toby.

"Toby" you screamed hugging him. " are *tic.* you ok *tic* baby girl." He asked and you nodded "thanks to you Toby" you said and he patted the back of your head.
" now what *tic* do we do with him?" Toby asked and you smirked at him.

*time skip brought to you by Frostfire*

You and Toby were currently playing hide and seek in the house until a shoe came out of nowhere and you about tripped and fell on your face but Toby caught you and added " looks like *tic* I caught you, now it's * tic*my turn to be it." Toby said and smirked but instead of getting the response he wanted you than began to run down the hall screaming " that's not how the game works Toby."

You were currently hiding in a laundry basket for the last 2 hours with a ton a clothes when you heard the door creak. You tried your best to breathe quite which only made you louder ( if your like me) suddenly the laundry basket was tipped over and you fell out. "Found *tic* you" Toby said. You tried to scramble away but he grabbed onto your waist. "*tic* is someone *tic* being a bad kitty *tic*"

You thought for a moment you were not sure but you knew you wanted it and so did he you couldn't say no it would make him more unstable than he already is

" yes I've been a bad kitty I think I need to be punished." You said "as you wish *tic* my lady" he said picking you up and carrying you to your bed. Toby began to kiss you and take off your shirt but with all his tics you had to help him. Once he had it off he began to kiss your neck searching for your sweet spot it took him a while but finally you let out a tiny moan and he smirked in victory. After abusing that for a while leaving a donut sized hickey. He began to move to getting off your bra. Which he was very unsuccessful at and kept grunting as he tried to do it. You giggled to this and then helped him. Finally getting his prize he began to suck causing you to moan. "T-Toby" you stuttered and you could feel him smirk against your breast. He went to undressing the rest of you and bent down towards you womanhood licking around it and giving hickeys to your legs. " just do it!" You shouted
"Do what y/n, use your *tic* words come on speak *tic* up." He said
"Just fuck me already!" You shouted
"As you wish my lady." He said he began to take off his shirt revealing the strongest abs you have ever seen. He than took off his pants and thru his boxers underneath you could see a huge buldge.
" must be painful, let me help" you said seductively as you pulled his boxers down. You than saw a (insert size) dick and looked away in embarrassment.
"Your right *tic* y/n it did." And without further warning he thrust into shoving in his full length. You cried out in pain.
"Toby I'm a virgin!" You shouted.
"I'm so sorry we can stop if you want." He said actually feeling sorry. You knew he needed this tho so as a response he began to buck your hips and he let out a moan and began moving with you. You squealed in delight as the pain soon melted into pleasure " that's it meow *tic* for me kitty." He said. Every time he ticked you cold feel his member do it inside of you at the same time. You both were panting and moaning and he was grunting. He kissed your cheek with a little tic that made you blush

"I'm almost*tic*  there!" He shouted

"Me too!" You shouted releasing "but not inside."

"Why not" he asked starting to feel sad.
"It's not you Toby I'm just not ready for that." You replied
"As you wish." He said kissing you again. Soon his thrust were slow and sloppy and he began twitching a lot more. He pulled out of you and with a lot of neck cracking and twitching he released all over the bed and feel beside you

" I love you y/n" he said

"I love you to Toby"

MEANWHILE DOWNSTAIRS

Cocoa (me oc) was sitting on ej lap watching my little pony . Cocoa and jack were listening to do noises they were making and Jack looked over to her "want to go upstairs" he asked "*chirp* yes n-nya" she answered
"I wonder where there going" Jeff asked and Ben smirked (here let author -chan give you a hint ..... Mating rituals mwahahaha, lol no just the norm , or so you thought)