Who's That Girl? Jughead x Reader

3K 35 3
                                    

This oneshot is a song one shot. The song is
"Who's that Girl?" By Hilary Duff.

"There were places we would go at midnight
There were secrets that nobody else would know
There's a reason but I don't know why
I don't know why
I don't know why
I thought they all belonged to me"

You were walking down the halls of Riverdale high thinking about your ex and all you two would do together. You would sneak out of your house just to see him.  He repays you by breaking up with you. You never knew why until today.
   "Who's that girl?
Where's she from?
No she can't be the one
That you want
That has stolen my world
It's not real, it's not right
It's my day, it's my night
By the way
Who's that girl living my life?
Oh no, living my life"

You looked over and saw Jughead and Betty. The blonde "little miss perfect" cheerleader that is now living your life. You knew Veronica and Archie were trying to hide this from you but eventually secrets come out.
"This isn't real." You thought and sighed.
You gave one final look at the two and breathed in and walked away.

"Seems like everything's the same around me
Then I look again and everything has changed
I'm not dreaming so I don't know why
I don't know why
I don't know why
She's everywhere I wanna be"

You looked around the halls and saw everything. Everything you saw was the same as before  yet it all felt so strange. 
You sat down in class and in front of you was Betty and Jughead.  You pinched yourself and it hurt so you knew you weren't dreaming and this was all reality.

"Who's that girl?
Where's she from?
No she can't be the one
That you want
That has stolen my world
It's not real, it's not right
It's my day, it's my night
By the way
Who's that girl living my life?"

You looked at the two and you just wanted to cry.  Betty stole your whole world. You wanted to be Jughead's one but she stole him away. 

"I'm the one who made you laugh
Who made you feel
And made you sad
I'm not sorry
For what we did
For who we were
I'm not sorry
I'm not her"

You watched as the two laughed together. You thought that how you would make him laugh when he was sad. How he was the only one that could make you laugh. 
But you weren't fully wishing you were Betty because you knew to smile because it happened.  You weren't Betty. Betty wasn't you. You knew that wishing you were her wasn't going to happen. 

"Who's that girl?
Where's she from?
No she can't be the one
That you want
That has stolen my world
It's not real, it's not right
It's my day, it's my night
By the way
Who's that girl living my life?
Oh no, living my life"

Class was over and you sighed watching the two holding hands.
"She's living what my life was." You mumbled.
You walked out of class in front of them and you saw Reggie smiling at you.  You smiled back and you hugged him.
Although you were happy with Reggie watching Betty and Jughead made you feel jealous.
  Reggie smiled at you and held your hand and you smiled walking behind "Bughead".
"Oh no living my life." You thought.
  

Riverdale Preferences Where stories live. Discover now