Lets Go To Neverland! (Yandere! Peter Pan X Male Reader)

Chapter 9

Peter looked at you and frowned. "Way to ruin the story Y/N." He pouted. "Oh shut up! You can't just kill someone because you don't like them! He didn't even do anything to you!"

Before you could continue to shout at Peter, the Lost Boys cheered and jumped up, tackling Peter.

"You really killed him?! Wow!!!"
"Yay! The Codfish is dead!"

They all began to chant "Hook is dead!"

You sighed and held your head, getting a headache. Why were they so happy about this? Sure, they we're always sort of enemies with Captain Hook, but it was always kind of like a game to them. So why go as far as kill him? You we're definitely confused and didn't seem to be getting any answers.

Peter laughed and looked at you. "Oh come on Y/N. Don't be such a downer." You didn't even know how to respond to anything. Peter clearly didn't seem to care that you just saw a dead man right in front of you. What if you were traumatized?! Did he just not care?

You sighed and walked away from them and went to Peter's room where your pallet on the floor was at. You sat down and covered yourself with the blanket, leaving Peter Pan and the Lost Boys in the other room.

Peter sighed. "Alright boys. Maybe you all should go to bed." They all whined.

"But I don't wanna!" Cubby pouted and sat on the floor, crossing his arms.

"Well, what if I tell you a story?" Peter looked at the boys as they looked at him and nodded quickly. They all ran to their beds and lied down, looking at Peter expectantly. Peter sat and began to tell them one of his stories that they had probably heard a thousand times about one of his adventures.

Meanwhile, you sat in Peter's room and tried to clear your mind. You couldn't stop thinking about how upset Mr. Smee looked. You lied down and tried to forget about your day. Maybe it was alright? Captain Hook is supposed to be the bad guy, so maybe he deserved to die? He did threaten to kill you after all.

You brought your hand to your neck and felt where his hook cut you slightly. You never got a chance to take care of the wound, so there was dried blood left on your neck. And of course Peter was too worried about telling his amazing story instead of making sure you were okay. Asshole.

You sighed and lied down on your side as you closed your eyes. Right as you started trying to fall asleep, you heard Peter walk into the room.

"Y/N. Are you awake?" He walked over to you. You didn't respond since you were almost asleep anyways, but Peter shook you slightly. "Y/N, wake up."

You sighed and opened your eyes. "What?" You turned to look at him and he seemed to just notice the cut on your neck. He didn't say anything about it, but he slowly reached out and touched your neck, making you flinch slightly.

"Ah, sorry, Does it hurt?" You shook your head. "Not really.." You covered the cut and turned back on your side.

Peter grabbed you and pulled you up, making you sit up next to him. "See? Captain Hook is a bad man. He deserved to die. What if he killed you?"

"Well it doesn't help that you told him to kill me!" Peter's eyes widened a bit. "Well I didn't mean it like that obviously! I wanted to trick him."

"Well that didn't work out great for you, now did it?" You huffed and looked away from him. He moved closer and hugged you.

"I'm sorry Y/N. I'm not always good at making decisions in stressful situations. I always act without thinking, so things don't always turn out the way I want it to. I just wanted to protect you. I don't know what I would have done if Hook had killed you.."

You felt like his words were... Weird. Peter wasn't one to just talk about things like that. His tone of voice made him sound sincere and upset, not something your used to coming from him.

You hesitantly hugged him back and rested your head on his shoulder. "It's alright I guess... You were trying to do something good.. But you still shouldn't kill people." He nodded.

"I'm just glad you aren't mad." Peter laughed softly and smiled at you. "But im sure your tired. I'll let you get some sleep." He leaned close to your ear and whispered. "Goodnight Y/N~ Sweet dreams~" He rubbed your back and kissed your cheek quickly before standing and leaving the room, not even going to his hammock that he sleeps in.

You sat there and stared at the curtain door that Peter walked out of for a few moments before lying down and trying to fall asleep, rubbing your cheek. Peter is... Complicated. To say the least.