Lets Go To Neverland! (Yandere! Peter Pan X Male Reader)

Chapter 34

(I would like to point out that the art for the cover of this story was not made by me. It was made by someone on Instagram called how_does_one_social. They actually posted the original picture on a different acc and I can't remember the name now since it's been so long. I only remember the name of this account since I always thought it was kind of funny XD Anyways, I just wanted to point that out because I noticed I never gave any credit to the original artist.)

(HhhhHHhhHhhhhhhh.... No ones POV!)

You sat in Peters lap as he sifted through the toys, covering your eyes so whatever he chose would be a surprise. "Am I limited to just one toy~" Peter cooed in your ear, sending shivers down your spine. "I-It doesn't matter. You can choose however many you want." 

You knew he would at least get a rope for sure. He always did. You weren't sure how you felt about it. It was exciting in it's own weird way, but not being able to move proved to not only be uncomfortable, but it would sometimes make you a little panicky. He once tied you up and left a vibrator in you while he went to go clean the kitchen. It was his punishment for you since you were asked to clean the kitchen hours before hand. You just didn't feel like doing it. 

You jumped slightly as Peter replaced his hand with cloth, covering your eyes and tying the blindfold tight so it wouldn't slip. You could hear the drawer close as Peter picked you up and carried you to the bed. You could feel whatever toy he had picked for you touch your leg. It felt cold, probably leather. That wasn't very telling though considering he had a lot of leather toys in that drawer. 

Peter set you down on the bed and lied you down rather gently. You could feel something cold wrap around your neck. You knew exactly what it was when you heard a soft jingling sound. It was the leather collar that Peter would often make you wear. He said it was fitting considering you were his Kitten. 

Peter cupped your face in his hands and smiled softly as he admired the big bell and collar around your neck. There was even a little bow on the bell since you once told him that it looked kind of boring in your opinion.

You weren't at all surprised when you felt a rope being tied around your wrists. Peter tied your arms above your head, connecting the rope to the bed post. You tugged on the rope, assuring it was secure. What you weren't expecting was for Peter to tie up your legs as well. He lifted your leg, wrapping the rope behind your knee and tying it to the bed post, keeping your leg up in the air and spread open. He did the same with your other leg and ran his hands along your inner thighs. You shivered at the touch and the feeling of not having any control. Peter leaned down and kissed you, trailing the kisses down to your neck, and then to your chest, stopping to suck and bite at your nipples. You jumped, your member twitching as it was neglected. You whimpered as your position made it difficult to rub yourself against Peter.

While his mouth was working with your nipples, Peters hands roamed your body, touching everywhere other than your twitching member. You decided to speak up. "Mm, D-Daddy~ Please~" You spoke quietly, almost like a soft squeak. Peter chuckled, moving his hands closer to your member but just out of reach, teasing you as he knew what you wanted. 

"Silly Kitten~ I'm in charge. You don't get a say in what happens now.~" You pouted, feeling the weight of the bed shift as Peter reached to grab something. A click was heard, followed by a light buzzing. You whimpered at the sound. "I-I don't want that..." You tried to pull your knees together to block Peter, but the rope kept your legs apart.

"You told me to choose for you. And you told me to get however many toys I want. We're gonna be playing for a while~" Peter gave no warning as he pressed the vibrator against your entrance, causing you to squirm. You turned your head in an attempt to cover your mouth with your arm. This proved to be quite difficult as your neck began to hurt. Peter watched you struggle to hold back your soft moans and watched as your member leaked precum, the tip red and longing to be touched. He pulled the vibrator away from your entrance, earning a sigh from you, only to press it against your sensitive head.

"A-Ah! D-Daddy!~ S-Stop~ I-It's t-too sensitive!" Peter of course ignored his Kittens plea, trailing the device down his kittens shaft to the base and back up to the tip. Peter watched as you wiggled and writhed in pleasure and pain, the vibrating irritating your sensitive member. 

...

Some time later and now the vibrator is actually inside you, driving you kind of crazy. Since he didn't have to hold the vibrator anymore, he figured he could put some other toys to work. "You're gonna have to be still, okay? You don't want this to hurt more than it's already going to." Soon, you could feel something press against the head of your member. You gasped as it slipped in. You were quite sure things weren't meant to go up there. "A-Ah~ D-Daddy, what is that?" Peter chuckled softly. "It's a sounding rod. It's usually used by doctors, but I figured this could be fun too."

The rod was slim, metal, and cold. Peter moved it slowly in and out of your urethra. It stung, but it only hurt worse when you tried to move. It gave you the sensation of needing to pee, and while all this was happening, your insides were still vibrating violently. All of these weird feelings together were getting to be too much for you, and you could feel yourself nearing your climax. 

"You're not ready to cum already, are you kitten?~" Peter wrapped his hand tight around your member, stopping you from cumming as he continued fucking your even smaller hole with the metal rod.

"P-Please let me cum! It hurts!" Peter only shook his head. "This is what happens when you give me this much power over what happens to you~ Now you can only lie here and take what I give you~"

...

Some more time later, there's even more toys being used. Nipple clamps, another vibrator, a dildo. Peter even brought the knife out, leaving cuts all over his babies skin. Meanwhile, you could barely keep yourself awake. Peter had finally let you cum again, multiple times actually, but the night never seemed to end. The two of you went through multiple rounds of sex and he did all sorts of things to you with the various toys, all while you were tied up, unable to get away. It's not like you wanted to anyways. Sure you were exhausted, but this is what you asked for, and it was the best night you had ever had. When Peter was finally too tired to go on and felt bad for your small, abused body, he untied you and helped clean you up. After cleaning up, he held you in his arms and lied down with you in bed, holding you close.

"Y/N..."

You lazily hummed a response.

"I love you kitten... I'm glad you stayed with me~" 

You smiled weakly, burying your face in Peter's chest. "I love you too... I'm glad I stayed too~" 

The room was quiet, the only sound being heavy pants as you and Peter attempted to catch your breath. Some time passed, Peter fell asleep, and you felt yourself drift away into a dreamless sleep as you nuzzled against your capture. A thought crossed your mind before you finally fell asleep.

Did you really stay with him? The more your thoughts drifted, the more you realized you never really had a choice, and soon, you were asleep in the arms of a "man" who didn't even deserve you.

𝕿𝖍𝖊 𝕰𝖓𝖉