Everything Scary

They Shouldnt Have

She shouldn't have done it.

It was Halloween Night and Karlee had four of her friends over. They decided to play Bloody Mary. Two of them chickened out. So Karlee, Sara and Kelly decided to do it by themselves. They did it two times. Nothing. The third time, they decided to play a trick on the other two. They did it and they each let out a blood chilling scream. They each ran out of the bathroom, mascara running down their faces (they rubbed their eyes with water).

Jessi and Emily frantically asked "What? What happened in there?!" The three of them just stood there and shook their heads like they were traumatized by what happened(didn't)in the bathroom. After awhile the three burst out laughing. "Oh I hate you guys!" Jessi screamed. The next day, Karlee was watching T.V., alone, and all the sudden the power went out. She grabbed a flashlight and she had to go to the bathroom. As She was going, she shreiked at what she saw, in blood, on the mirror. It read: You Shouldn't Have. The police and Karlee's parents found her frozen in fear and dead in her own blood. The same thing happened to Kelly and Sara. The police were baffled by the pattern. Emily and Jessi were very shaken up the next few days.

At the three girl's visitation, they were laid in white coffins. At the burial, everyone screamed at what they saw. In blood, was written: They Shouldn't Have on each of the coffins.

To this day, Emily and Jessi are in mental hospitals. They are practically mute. Except every once in a while, they will mutter, in a hushed, creepy sort of tone: They Shouldn't Have.

.

.

.

.

.

http://www.everythingscary.com/story/they-shouldny-have.html