Unexpected Guests? REWRITE

I Don't Even Like Myself

We sat around on the couch, me stuck between Alois and Ciel and the two butlers on the other side of. There were crazy dares and truths being thrown around. At one point I had to wear Ciel's eyepatch then another where Alois had to admit that he thought Sebastian was an alright butler. 

When Alois turned to me to ask truth or dare- ready for revenge for making him go outside and scream at all the neighbors- I automatically picked truth, not wanting to risk what dares he had in store. With a smirk, he said, "Who here are you most in love with?"

I rolled my eyes, "No one, I don't even like myself."

Alois rolled his eyes and crossed his arms because he knew that was just a valid answer to his question. Smiling, it was my turn and I looked at Sebastian, watching his eyes go to quick fuchsia pink for a second before going back to normal. 

"So, Sebastian, butler guy, Satan wearing Prada, truth or dare?"

He let out a low chuckle, trying to throw me off my smooth track and it slightly worked, and said, "Dare."

I internally flipped and tried to think of crazy dare for him to do. I did not expect him to pick dare, I didn't think he was that brave.  "Uh, fuck, okay. I dare you to-" I looked around the room for something but nothing came to mind. "I dare you, Mister Michaelis, to-Shit, hold on- Oh, just sit on my lap for the rest of the game."

Sebastian slowly moved onto my lap, not questioning anything and smirking at the big blush on my face. Ciel covered his mouth so his amused smile wouldn't show, his shoulders moving ever so slightly as he let out a bit of laughter. Alois, on the other hand, didn't know what to say and was surprised Sebastian actually went through with the dare.

Sebastian looked back at me, saying, "Truth or dare?"

"Looks like I'm stuck with truth," I said, looking him up and down as he sat comfortably. 

He eyed me, glancing at his master for a second; that really gave away what he was going to ask. "How much do you truly know about all of us?"

"Uh, really? You guys are still on that?" I situated Sebastian to sit more comfortably on my lap before I answered. "Listen, I know enough that-" I was cut off by someone knocking on the door. Talk about being saved by the bell. 

Pushing Sebastian off, I jumped over the couch to go to the door, ignoring the disappointed groans from the rest of the group. I rolled my eyes before throwing the door open to see the one person that shouldn't have been there. Pinkie, the girl from the mall. 

"What the fuck," I said and started to slowly shut the door, though, she put her foot in the way before I could. 

"Listen, I swear I'm not here to attack your friends," She said, walking into my house uninvited. 

I furrowed my eyebrows and mumbled, "Please, come in, it's not like this house doesn't have enough crazy."

She twirled toward me, her pink ponytail slightly smacking my face. "Anyway, to get introductions out of the way, I'm Hana, and I'm sorry about..." She trailed off to look at everyone on the couch. "Why are they still wearing their costumes?"

"They're really into Black Butler, you know like most people are. It's a really popular manga." Thought, my statement didn't convince her at all and she continued forward toward the group who seemed ready to bolt. 

Hana went up to Ciel and leaned toward him, squinting her eyes and studying really hard on his face, then without a second beat she tore off his eyepatch. 

"Hey!" I said and stood between the two of them. "What the fuck is your problem?"

Ciel automatically covered his eye out of instinct and turned away trying to conceal his seal. Hana moved past me to grab his wrist, jerking his hand away to see the seal on his eye. I glanced to Alois who had his mouth shut tightly, which by the strength of this girl, I didn't blame him.