Shatter Me: Creepypasta X Reader

Chapter 3: The Greetings

Y/n POV

I couldn't believe it...
Almost all of the most well-known creepypastas were standing right in front of us...
The creepypastas were all silent, so I took it as an opportunity to get a good look at the creepypastas.
I saw Ticci, I call Ticci Toby that for short.
Masky
Hoodie
Trendorman
Splendorman
...oh no... Offenderman with that horrible grin on his face... We're gonna have to watch out...
Omg no way!! JEFF THE KILLER!!! But he didn't look too happy...
Then I saw... BEN!
I ducked behind Slenderman, knowing that I sometimes get scared of BEN because of the Unhealing song used in his backstory.
I managed to calm myself down and slowly peek back at him.
He was looking at me... I gave him a small smile. He smiled back. I blushed a tiny blush. But I think he still noticed because he smirked at me.
"What, the FUCK are you doing coming back with two human girls, Slender? I thought you said yourself that you're not allowed to bring back any humans!!!"
I could recognize by the voice and the curse word that Jeff had said that.
I looked in his direction and gave him a cross between an innocent look, an admiration look, and a scared look, plus the blush was still there.
Jeff noticed and I don't think he really cared.
"Jeff, they are here to become proxies," Slenderman said calmly.
Jeff rolled his eye, knowing that there was really no point in arguing with Slender.
Tiffinee and I slowly walked out from behind Slenderman.
We walked over to the creepypastas.
"Wow...," Tiffinee said in awe.
I was too shy to say anything. But Tiffinee walked straight up to Masky.
"Hi Masky! I'm Tiffinee, Tiffinee Nickson! Nice to meetcha!"
Soon all of the creepypastas started to talk to her, well, except Jeff. He was looking angrily in our direction. He saw that I was alone and he smiled his insane smile.
I gulped.
"I don't know why you guys came here," he said while walking towards me. "But sooner or later you will die."
He had his knife out. I looked at it in awe... It was an actual Jeff knife!!!
Jeff saw that I had interest in his knife and said, "You like the knife ,huh? Well, how about you get a CLOSER LOOK AT IT!"
He held the knife to my neck and shoved me against the wall. I let out a quiet Yelp. He chuckled.
"Jeff! Stop it!,"
We looked over to see Eyeless Jack with his hands on his waist.
Jeff looked back at me and growled before letting me go. I fell against the wall and sat on the floor, holding my neck to make sure it was alright.
"Are you ok?"
I looked up to see Eyeless Jack kneeling in front of me.
I nodded and blushed shyly. E.J. (Eyeless Jack) noticed and sat down next to me.
"You're shy, aren't you," he asked.
I nodded.
"So's Hoodie," he said
"I know," I said.
He chuckled, "you know just about everything about us. You and her right?"
He pointed to Tiffinee who was talking to Masky, Hoodie, and Ticci.
"Yes..."
EJ noticed how I looked longingly at the group of creepypastas.
"Do you wanna go meet them," he asked.
"I would if weren't so shy," I said sadly.
"Come with me, I at least want you to meet Toby, BEN, and Hoodie," he said, standing up and offering me his hand.
I shyly took it and he led me towards the group of pastas.
"Toby, BEN, Hoodie! Come with me," he said.
The three pastas went over to him.
"Wh-what is it, E-EJ," Ticci asked.
"And who is this beautiful young lady," BEN asked.
I blushed, remembering how I blushed when he had smiled back at me.
"This is y/n," EJ said.
"Hi BEN, hi Hoodie, hi Ticci," I said shyly.
"Ti-Ticci," Ticci said surprised.
"S-s-s-sorry.. I-I li-like-like- I like to c-call you th-that inste-stead o-of T-Toby," I said a little bit shy, scared, and worried.
"You sound just like him," Hoodie said, annoyed.
"S-sorry. I...I do that when I'm nervous...," I said.
"N-no need to-to be n-nervous! I-I'm just n-not used t-to b-being called T-Ticci instead o-of Toby," he said happily.
I smiled at him, he smiled back. I could tell by the way his mouth guard moved.
    "So, gorgeous, do you like to play video games," BEN asked.
    "I like to play..." I thought about it for a moment until I said.
    "I like to play Five Nights At Freddy's, all of the games, and..."
    I tried to think of other games I liked to play but I couldn't really think of any.
   "Wow, I guess I just don't play enough games..." I said, embarrassed.
   "It's okay! Maybe we can play some fnaf later," BEN said.
   "O-okay," I said.
    "Hey, guys! I have some questions for ya! Especially you, Toby," Tiffinee yelled at the pastas that were with me.
    "Seeya later, y/n," they all said.
    I waved and sat by the wall again. I really don't know what it is with me and walls, but I always find myself by them.
    I looked around at the pastas until I saw... Offenderman...
    He was staring me with a huge smile on his face. I flinched back against the wall. He smirked, then teleported away.
I'm so dead, I thought.

                                                                               🔮🔮🔮

It was evening and most of the pastas had gone to bed.
    "There are no free rooms at the moment," Slender said to Tiffinee and I. "I do not know where you two will sleep tonight."
    "We can stay down here on the couch," Tiffinee said happily. "We don't mind!"
    "Yeah! I'm used to it anyways," I said.
    "Don't worry Slender, I can watch them from the TV," BEN said, and winked at me.
   I blushed.
    "... Alright, but I trust you, BEN," Slender said.
    Tiffinee and I got comfortable on the couch, but I felt like someone was watching me, and it wasn't BEN.
    "You ok, y/n," Tiffinee asked.
   "Yeah, I'm fine," I said.
    I shook off the feeling and went to sleep.

                                                                              🔮🔮🔮

   I woke up to the sound of movement. I looked at my phone, it was about two in the morning. BEN and Tiffinee were asleep.
    I heard a clatter, and a chuckle behind me. I whipped around, but nothing was there. I turned around, only to be face to face with...

Oh no..., I thought.