(really old, but keeping it because this was the first fanfiction cover I made.)
Your girl, Emily loves Supernatural so it's safe to say I had fun with this one.
It took me quite a bit of time but I was able to make this. I made a lot of different font choices... I just couldn't seem to find the right one. If you want to give it a go, here's the picture....
Now, for the covers
↓ I just moved the title down with this one and added the quote↓
And I made a bonus aesthetic because I felt a little guilty for forgetting