Torn In Three | Malum, Muke, Mashton

Chapter Twenty-one

-Michael's point of view-
"That could be arranged," Luke said.

I froze, shocked by how open and excited Luke was about the idea of a band foursome. Was he just confident he's the best?

I looked ahead of me to see Calum as shocked as I was, and Ashton looking at Luke with disgust. Disgust.

"You're joking, right?" Ashton said.

"Who would joke about wanting sex with me-"

"Shut up, Michael." Calum cut me off.

I watched as Luke walked over towards Ashton and kneeled down in front of him. "Do you have any better ideas? Anything more satisfying?"

Ashton hesitantly shook his head. "But what if I don't want Michael," he said.

"Then just go with me." Luke answered.

Still frozen in my seat, I looked towards Calum staring at Ashton who was contemplating on whether he should fuck me. It took me by surprise when the boy grinned and walked over to where Luke and Ashton sat. "Come on Ash," was all I could hear before Calum started whispering in Ashton's ear, and then Luke's.

What Calum said must have convinced Ashton, because he quickly started undressing. Within seconds he was stripped down to only his boxers and revealing his toned stomach. "Come here, Clifford." Ashton said.

I still sat in my seat, unaware of what was happening. This is supposed to help me choose who my favourite is? "Do I have to?"

Ashton nodded. "If you don't, then I'll have to come over there and get you myself."

I stood up. When I neared the three boys, Luke grabbed me and pulled me down onto the floor where he now sat. Once again I made no attempt to move, as Luke did all the moving for me. He pulled off my black tank top, and then pushed me down to take off my skinny jeans. Luke licked his lips, then undressed himself.

"How are we going to do this?" I spoke once Luke was only in his boxers. Only Calum remained fully clothed, standing over us.

"Just follow our lead." Ashton replied.

I nodded, nervous and excited butterflies in my stomach. "Okay."

"Now, Michael, who should get naked first?"

"Well, since Calum still has clothes on, I vote him."

Calum did as told. Once I counted exactly thirty seconds, the boy stood before me, stark naked. "Okay, now who?" Calum said, still standing.

"Ashton."

Ashton followed Calum, but only this time had to pull off some flimsy boxers. He smiled when done, his length extremely close to my face, and sat back down. "Luke, your turn."

Luke threw his boxers to the far side of the room with no struggle. He was obviously ready for this. "Michael, get naked."

I nodded, not wanting to be left out. I threw my boxers to where Luke's were, then looked at all three boys: Luke was grinning, glee and excitement shining in his eyes. It was evident Calum was a little nervous, but this was our first foursome. Ashton - he was unreadable. He stared at me, in my eyes of course, and waited patiently, as if to get this over and done with. "Now what?"

No one spoke, but Luke leaned forward and started massaging my back. He hummed whilst doing so, making my back arch in satisfaction. Once I arched, Ashton lunged forward and sat next to me. I watched as he nodded towards Calum, then out of nowhere took me in his grip. Ashton pumped slowly and teasingly, crookedely smiling when I moaned.

"A-Ash," I managed to stutter, my body not used to so much contact. As if it would help, Calum finally made and appearance and started kissing my lips, hungrily moving into my mouth and tasting me. "Calum,"

"Luke," Luke said.

Ashton's pumping began to grow faster and I couldn't help the groan that escaped my mouth. Once the noise escaped my lips, Luke gripped onto my back tighter, causing a contrast of pain. "Ouch- ARGH." I continued to make pointless noises until Calum shut me up again by bringing his lips to mine.

"Shh, Michael."

I stopped making noise.

"Now answer my questions," Calum said.

"Now?" I replied, looking down towards Ashton who was still pumping, beginning to get even faster.

"Now." Calum confirmed. "Who's giving the most pleasure right now?"

That was pretty easy. "Ashton."

Calum pushed Ashton away, forcing the pumping to stop. Calum then proceeded to start where Ashton left off, causing me to moan louder than I had before. "Now who?"

"You."

Calum smiled, and continued with what he was doing. He bit his lip, with full concentration on me.

"How is my massaging?" Luke asked, his hands now travelling to my ass.

"Great," I nearly screeched due to what Calum was doing. My breath hitched in my throat when Luke pinched me. I couldn't see him from behind, but I knew for certain that he was smiling.

"Ashton, come here." Luke said.

Ashton moved away from where he watched Calum, then sat behind me with Luke. I moaned once the golden-haired boy's lips came into contact with my neck, and then even louder when I felt his teeth. "Fuck,"

"Now who's giving the most pleasure?" Ashton asked.

I took a deep breath and held it, trying to think. Calum continued to pump quickly, nearly bringing me to my climax. But then I felt Ashton's hair tickle my cheek, and Luke palm my ass. "Luke."

Calum gripped onto me even tighter than before at my comment, earning more satisfied noises to escape my lips. "Really?"  He said.

"I'm going to-" I ignored Calum. Luke quickly jumped from his place, leaving Ashton to finish what Luke started. Luke moved Calum away, bringing me into his hands. The sudden contact was enough to push me over the edge. I groaned, letting myself climax all over Luke, and creating a large mess. The image of Luke sitting infront of me was only too good, making the current pleasure even better. "Come." I finished my sentence.

"Look at me," Calum said. I did as told. "Now look at Ashton, then Luke." I looked at Ashton, who seemed flustered, then Luke; still smiling.

"Apologise for cheating on all three of us." Ashton said.

"I'm sorry" I looked down towards the floor that had a mess created by me.

"There's only one way we will accept your apology," Calum said.

"What's that?"

Calum looked towards Ashton, then Luke, then back to me. He smiled, "the person you choose gets to humiliate you."

I paused, fearful of my reputation being ruined - well, as much as it can after fighting Ashton on stage. "What if I don't choose anyone?"

"You will, Michael. You of all people should know we're too special to just let go of."

--
Hello sorry for the late update I was on holiday and forgot to tell you in the last update oops.
Okay so I had an idea. I don't know who Michael should choose, so I'm leaving it up to you guys. Within the next few hours I'll post an update where you can vote on Malum, Mashton or Muke. Please comment if you think that's a good idea!!
Also thank you so much for 40k reads you're all awesome and I love you thank you. Your comments and messages are what keep me going so please don't be shy to talk to me because I love that. :)
Okay bye
-Celia